33 properties for sale in Brushy Prairie

This is a Real Estate-Owned (REO)/post-foreclosure home owned or managed by a bank. All offers are considered; however, the highest and best will most likely be accepted

BACK ON THE MARKET AT NO FAULT OF THE SELLERS*Experience the best of Northeast Indiana lake living on Big Turkey Lakean all-sports lake known for its recreation and natural beauty. Nestled in the peaceful setting of Turtle Cove, this property offers a rare combination of privacy and scenic views, with abundant wildlife and calm waters perfect for paddle boarding, kayaking, and swimming. An added bonus of the cove location: no need to remove your pier and lift seasonally, offering convenience and extended enjoyment of your waterfront. This well-appointed home features 3 bedrooms, including a conveniently located primary suite on the main floor. The open-concept layout creates a seamless flow between living, dining, and kitchen spaces, while engineered hardwood flooring throughout adds warmth and a refined touch. Additional highlights include a 2-car attached garage and thoughtfully designed outdoor living spaces. A spacious composite deck provides durability and low-maintenance enjoymen

Welcome to lake living at Big Long Lake! This charming 1 1/2 story home offers the perfect blend of comfort, updates, and space to enjoy year-round or as a weekend retreat. Recent improvements include new roof, updated kitchen and bathroom, giving you a move-in ready home with modern touches. Enjoy the Big Long Lake lifestyle with a pier included in the sale! The pier is currently shared with a neighboring property and provides convenient access for boating, fishing, and lake fun. A detached bonus building features a spacious room and full bathroom. Ideal for a bunkhouse, man cave, game room, hobby space, or additional recreational use. Property to be sold'AS-IS'

Welcome to this charming country property offering privacy, flexibility, and plenty of space to make your own. Tucked along a quiet country road and surrounded by mature trees, this 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath home provides the peaceful setting so many buyers are searching for. Enjoy your morning coffee on the covered front porch while taking in the country views. Inside, both bedrooms feature walk-in closets, and the flexible floor plan includes a bonus room currently used as a laundry room that could serve as a potential third bedroom, home office, or additional living space. The half bath includes existing hookups, providing the option to relocate the laundry or explore the possibility of a full bath conversion. The home also features a pellet stove, offering a cozy secondary heat source during the colder months. Outside, you'll find even more to love with a 40x40 outbuilding, an attached 10x10 lean-to, and an additional storage shed that stays with the property. Whether you're looking for

Enjoy Big Turkey Lake living with lake views, access, and room to spread out! This 3-bedroom home sits on 6 lots totaling nearly half an acre and offers two pier spots, making it easy to enjoy all that Big Turkey Lake has to offer. Big Turkey is a popular all-sports lake, perfect for boating, fishing, swimming, and relaxing by the water. The home features a metal roof, updated HVAC, and many newer windows, along with an unfinished basement offering additional storage or future potential. The spacious lot, lake views, and detached garage add to the appeal of this unique lake-area property. Whether youre looking for a year-round home or a place to escape for weekends, this property offers a great opportunity to enjoy the Big Turkey Lake lifestyle

Discover the charm of 675 North Flint Road, a residential property that is ready for you to move in and make it your own. This inviting home, with its classic bungalow exterior, offers a delightful living experience from the moment you arrive. Step onto the welcoming porch, an ideal spot for morning coffee or evening relaxation, setting a peaceful tone for the entire residence. Restoration of the original woodworking throughout makes for a cozy fall retreat from chilly nights or having a mini split unit in each main living space provides ample temperature control for the summer heat and cold fall and winter nights. Tall ceilings in the finished basement featuring can lighting and a brand new epoxy floor, provide space for Winter activities out of the elements. With just under an acre the property provides a spacious backyard and back deck for entertaining. This property was newly renovated with new paint through out, new roof on garage, new plumbing, soft closing cabinets and drawers i

Move-in ready and meticulously renovated! Originally built in 1960, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home was extensively remodeled five years ago and offers approximately 1,200 square feet of comfortable living space. Improvements included updated plumbing and electrical, HVAC, metal roof, siding, and modern, comfortable interior updates, giving you the character of an established home with many of the major components already updated. The home is served by a 4-inch well and regional sewer system. With a LaGrange mailing address and a convenient Stroh-area location, you'll enjoy small-town living with easy access to nearby amenities, fishing, lakes, and outdoor recreation. Much of what the Stroh area has to offer is within walking distance. Whether you're looking for your first home, downsizing, or simply wanting a property where much of the work has already been completed, this one is ready for its next owner!

Don't miss this updated 3-bed, 2-full-bath home within walking distance of Big Turkey Lake. Updates include a new roof, fully renovated kitchen and bathrooms, new LVP flooring and carpet, new doors and appliances, fresh interior paint, and a newly stained front porch. A community pier slip list is available, but not guaranteed and public lake access is right down the road

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

Beautifully situated among mature trees, this well-maintained ranch offers comfortable one-level living on a. 42-acre lot. The home features 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a convenient 2-car attached garage. Enjoy peace of mind with a new roof in 2024 and furnace and central air replaced in 2020. The kitchen features a range with a built-in air fryer, new in 2019, adding convenience to everyday cooking. The partially fenced yard provides space for outdoor enjoyment while the beautiful trees create a private, inviting setting. A great opportunity to own a charming ranch with desirable updates and plenty of outdoor space! All appliances are included

Escape to the peaceful shores of Pretty Lake in LaGrange County, a quiet 184-acre fishing lake known for its clean water and impressive 23-foot water clarity. This charming furnished 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage offers approximately 610 square feet of thoughtfully arranged finished living space, perched high above the lake to capture stunning, bird's-eye views from the deck. With 48 feet of lake frontage, this property is perfectly suited for relaxing weekends, summer getaways, or year-round enjoyment. Spend your days fishing, swimming, kayaking, paddleboarding or simply unwinding on the deck while taking in the beautiful lake views. The property is offered furnished, making it easy to start enjoying immediately. Outdoor amenities include a boat dock, fire pit, and outdoor furniture, all included with the sale. For those looking for an investment opportunity, the property can be used as an Airbnb with a 30-day minimum stay, providing potential rental income while retaining the ability to

Located at 10570 W 100 S, LaGrange, Indiana, this unique 65 acre property in Steuben County offers an excellent combination of agricultural infrastructure, residential living, and income-producing potential. Much of the acreage is fenced and designed around an established pasture-raised poultry operation. At the heart of the property is an impressive 55' x 525' poultry facility, totaling approximately 28,875 square feet. The operation is currently set up for approximately 20,000 birds and includes two wells, solar panels for power, a backup generator, cooler, packing area, and extensive fenced pasture. The facility and supporting improvements were constructed in 2023, providing a newer setup for someone looking to continue or expand an agricultural operation. The property also features a 1,280-square-foot home with 3 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom, along with an attached two-car garage. Additional improvements include a 40' x 64' pole building with horse stalls, providing additional spac

The lake house without the old-lake-house compromises. Built in 2013 and now offered at $455,000, this Big Turkey Lake property gives you the space, modern construction, attached garage, and flexibility that can be hard to find with traditional lake homes. Situated on a rare double lot, the home offers more than 2,600 finished square feet, 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a spacious main-level primary suite, and an attached 2-car garage. And yes this home sits on the channel, and that is part of the appeal. Enjoy 124 feet of channel frontage, giving you a protected place for your boat with direct access out to Big Turkey Lake. You get the quieter, more sheltered setting at home while still enjoying the full lake lifestyle when you're ready to head out on the water. Inside, the open and spacious layout is ideal for both everyday living and entertaining, while approximately 700 additional square feet offers even more potential for future finished space. Whether you're searching for a full-time

Welcome to your Big Turkey Lake retreat! Nestled in Denisons Beach on an oversized 50 x 140 lot, this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home offers the ideal blend of easy lake living, modern mechanical updates, and deeded lake access to all-sports Big Turkey Lake. Inside, youll find a bright, efficient floor plan featuring 880 finished square feet of comfortable living space. The cozy living area connects seamlessly to the dining space and kitchen, maximizing every square foot for easy weekend relaxation or low-maintenance daily life. Key mechanical investments have already been handled for peace of mind, highlighted by a new furnace installed in 2024 (set up to easily connect central A/C) and a brand-new water heater (2024). Step outside to enjoy the serene lake surroundings from the covered open-frame front porch or unwind on the back deck after a day on the water. Whether you are searching for a turnkey weekend lake getaway, an investment opportunity, or low-maintenance year-round living

The lake house without the old-lake-house compromises. Built in 2013 and now offered at $455,000, this Big Turkey Lake property gives you the space, modern construction, attached garage, and flexibility that can be hard to find with traditional lake homes. Situated on a rare double lot, the home offers more than 2,600 finished square feet, 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a spacious main-level primary suite, and an attached 2-car garage. And yes this home sits on the channel, and that is part of the appeal. Enjoy 124 feet of channel frontage, giving you a protected place for your boat with direct access out to Big Turkey Lake. You get the quieter, more sheltered setting at home while still enjoying the full lake lifestyle when you're ready to head out on the water. Inside, the open and spacious layout is ideal for both everyday living and entertaining, while approximately 700 additional square feet offers even more potential for future finished space. Whether you're searching for a full-time

12.75 Private Acres Room for Everyone This spacious home offers incredible flexibility, with a full basement functioning as a complete second living space including its own kitchen, living room, bedrooms, and bathroom. Perfect for extended family or guests wanting their own space. In total, enjoy 6 bedrooms, 4 full baths, and a 4-car oversized garage for all your vehicles and gear. Set on 12.75 acres with over 5 wooded acres, it's a dream for nature lovers and hunting enthusiasts alike. Privacy, space, and versatility!

Looking for acreage, outbuildings and room to build some sweat equity? This one is packed with potential! Situated on approximately 1 acre, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers plenty of space, versatility and opportunity for the buyer ready to put in a little sweat equity. Located just east of Prairie Heights schools and school farm, the property enjoys a country setting with beautiful views of the surrounding farmland, mature trees and plenty of room to spread out. New furnace, well pump, bladder tank and garage roof. Inside, the home features an open living and dining area, three bedrooms, two full baths and a functional layout ready for your personal touches. Step outside to enjoy a front deck, back patio and a spacious, fully fenced yard great for pets, outdoor entertaining, gardening or simply enjoying the rural surroundings. One of the biggest bonuses is the two detached garages/outbuildings. One includes converted guest quarters, creating possibilities for additional living space

Welcome home to this spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home nestled on over 3 acres of beautiful property! Offering plenty of room both inside and out, this home combines comfortable living with recent updates and convenient features. Inside, youll find all-new paneling and flooring throughout, giving the home a fresh, updated feel. The kitchen features new appliances that will stay with the home, making it move-in ready for its new owners. With four bedrooms and three full bathrooms, there is plenty of space for family, guests, a home office, or whatever your needs may be. Outside, enjoy the privacy and possibilities that come with over 3 acres of land. The attached 2-car garage provides convenient parking and additional storage. The driveway has also been recently sealed, adding to the homes well-maintained appeal. With its generous acreage, updated interior, new kitchen appliances, and attached 2-car garage, this property offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy space, comfort, and a li

Secure your slice of lakefront on pristine Fish Lake! Boasting 65 feet of coveted, west-facing shoreline, you will enjoy spectacular sunset views almost every evening. The lot features a gentle slope topography protected by a durable concrete seawall, offering effortless, main-level living with minimal steps from the driveway all the way to the water's edge. The 3-bedroom home is a functional blank canvas with an open kitchen and living area positioned to maximize the waterfront views, making it an easy footprint to update and customize into your own lakeside retreat. Complete with an attached, oversized garage that has ideal workshop area and plenty of room for storage, this rare lake lot with over 1/3 acre is an economical way to get on this lake or a value add opportunity with unlimited potential. New roof, furnace and a/c 3 years ago

19th Century log home tucked away in a private little neighborhood with 80 feet of Big Turkey Lake Frontage, 1382 square feet of living space, 3 bedrooms. 1 bathroom. This home truly gives lake life vibes. Open floor plan on the main level along with the primary bedroom and bathroom. 2 bedrooms plus a loft space upstairs. Covered porch is a great place to unwind and enjoy the sunsets after a day on the water. The 30x 40 pole building right across the street has plenty of space to store your watercraft and lake toys, also a great space to entertain a large family gathering. Big Turkey Lake is a 450 Acre all sports lake from sun-up to sun down. 30 x 8 pier will remain with the home. Get ready to start making those lake-life memories

Space, privacy, and versatility come together on 1.5 acres in the Prairie Heights School District! This spacious 3-bedroom, 3-bath home offers an open main-level floor plan with vaulted ceilings, generous living and dining areas, and an attached 2-car garage. The fully finished walkout basement adds exceptional living space with a second kitchen, full bathroom, and a dedicated 1-car garage door-ideal for extra vehicle storage, hobbies, or a workshop. Enjoy peaceful country surroundings, wildlife views, and neighbors no closer than approximately an eighth of a mile. Recent updates include fresh carpet, durable luxury vinyl plank flooring, an on-demand water heater, newer roof, and updated furnace. Plenty of space inside and out-come see everything this property has to offer!

Lakefront Living on Henry Lake! This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers an incredible 235+ feet of lakefront with beautiful views and the perfect setting for enjoying everything lake life has to offer. Henry Lake is known for it's great fishing, while access to Big Turkey Lake, a popular ski lake, gives you even more opportunities for boating and recreation. Relax on the inviting deck overlooking the water, enjoy the private pier, or simply take in the peaceful lake views. Inside, you'll find a custom oak kitchen featuring a center island, large pantry, and an abundance of storage. A brand-new metal roof adds peace of mind for years to come. The adorable shed provides convenient storage and could also offer additional space for hobbies or other uses. With an amazing amount of lakefront, beautiful surroundings, and access to two lakes, this is a wonderful opportunity to enjoy the best of lake living!

Discover lakeside living at its finest on the quiet shores of Green Lake, where privacy, space come together on a rare. 75-acre setting with 230 feet of frontage across 5 parcels. Tucked away on a dead-end road with no public access and surrounded by a nature preserve, this west-facing property offers peaceful seclusion and sweeping water views and incredible sunsets. This spacious 5-bedroom, 5-bath home is designed for both everyday comfort and entertaining. The main living room features a cozy gas insert fireplace, while the large sunroom with expansive windows captures panoramic lake views. A unique mother-in-law suite provides its own private living space complete with a bedroom, bath, kitchen, and living area, perfect for guests. Outside the main home, youll find a bonus cabana room attached via the garage and/or exterior access, an ideal all-weather entertaining space on the lake side, twenty beautiful different species of trees on the property. Additional features include an ove

Auction! This amazing 16+ acre property is set to sell at Phone Bid Auction on September 10th at 5pm! The posted starting bid is the starting bid not the buy it now price. This property has 2 houses on the property and is set up for horses or live stock with a large barn with boxes stalls and a large attached heated shop building. The main house has 3 bedroom and 2 baths with the large heated shop that also has a 2 bedroom 1 bath apartment. This building has in floor heat throughout and also a full HVAC unit. The second home is a 3 bedroom 2 bath and was completely remodeled in 2021. The property is perfect for those that enjoy the outdoors and hunting with plenty of wildlife and conveniently located across the road from Pigeon River Reserve (Mango) with 10,000+ acres of additional land to hunt and enjoy. Auction Open Houses are set for August 6&13&20&7 Sept 3 from 3-5pm

Let your dreams become your reality. Opportunity meets waterfront living on beautiful Big Long Lake. This lakefront property has already been taken down to the studs, giving the next owner a true head start on creating the home or weekend retreat they've been dreaming about. Whether your vision is restoring the existing footprint or exploring future possibilities, much of the preliminary work has already been completed. The existing ranch offers approximately 765 square feet with a layout that previously featured two bedrooms and one full bath. The structure sits on a 50 x 120 lakefront lot with approximately 50 feet of shoreline and includes a firm sandy swimming area, a four-foot-wide pier, and exceptional views across one of northeast Indiana's most desirable all-sports lakes. Several valuable improvements and planning items are already in place. A new well has been installed. Electrical service is on site and currently disconnected. A recent survey, elevation certificate, and geote

A truly exceptional property in LaGrange County two parcels totaling 40 acres with an impressive 1,200 feet of lakefront on beautiful Royer Lake and over 3,000 feet of combined road frontage (more than 2,000 feet on one side and 1,000 feet on the other). This property offers a rare blend of rolling farmland, mature trees and serene waterfront, making it an ideal setting for recreation, investment, or development. Currently zoned Agricultural and under cultivation, it provides both income potential and flexibility for future use. Included on the property is a 1,120 sq. Ft. home featuring 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, on a walkout basement already plumbed for second bathroom. The home is positioned to take in the quiet, rural surroundings and offers an excellent opportunity for guest quarters, or a temporary residence while you plan your dream build. Royer Lake is a peaceful, non-ski lake known for its great fishing and connection to Fish Lake, offering the best of quiet lake living with expansive

Very motivated seller with updated survey on file dated 9/26/2026 by ben taylor1432 s/f. 3 beds. 1 bath. Sleeps 16+! Parking for 8+! Ski Lakefront! HUGE detached garage new in 2014! Enjoy lake living on one of Northeast Indiana's premier all-sports lakes with this updated waterfront home on Big Long Lake. Situated on a deep 38' x 148' lakefront lot, the property offers elevated views of the water, an exceptional swimming beach, and multiple outdoor spaces designed for relaxing and entertaining. Inside, the home features 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath, including a primary bedroom with beautiful lake views. The open living area flows into the updated kitchen and is filled with natural light, while the screened porch provides the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind after a day on the lake. The unfinished walkout lower level offers approximately 300 square feet of storage, ideal for keeping lake gear, tools, and seasonal items organized. One of this property's standout feature

Motivated seller that says make an offer and in case you missed it they're throwing in a one year home warranty! 578 of an acre on fish and royer lake chain! 2 bedrooms. Open concept living. 50 feet of lakefront 3 lots in total: one lakefront with 50 linear feet and 2 more lots on the back directly behind this home. Exceptional neighbors. Enjoy lake life right away with immediate possession at closing, giving you plenty of time to make the most of the season before winter arrives and just in time for ice fishing. Same owners for nearly 30 years, this year-round Royer Lake home offers 2 bedrooms, a LARGE full bathroom, a 10' x 17' lakeside sunroom, and an attached 18' x 24' garage. Open concept living at it finest with updates including: vinyl plank flooring, tile flooring in the sunroom, a metal roof, vinyl siding, an updated furnace, and all kitchen appliances are included, making this home move-in ready so you can start enjoying lake life from day one. Inside from the attached garage

Discover your retreat in Northeast Indianas scenic Lake Country on beautiful Pretty Lake, a quiet, non-ski lake known for excellent fishing and serene surroundings. This thoughtfully maintained home sits on nearly an acre and features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and the potential for a 4th bedroom or home office. The updated kitchen is both functional and stylish, and the primary suite boasts a beautifully refreshed bathroom. Enjoy outdoor living with a walking trail that encircles the lake, perfect for morning strolls or evening sunsets. As a member of the Pretty Lake Association, youll have access to a vibrant conservation club with year-round activities and pickleball courts. The property also includes an additional lakefront lot, 15 x 43, complete with a permanent dock, giving you direct access to the water for fishing, kayaking, or simply relaxing by the lake. With this rare combination of space, updates, and lake access, this home is the ideal retreat for those seeking peace, nature

Experience lake living at its best! This adorable cottage on Pretty Lake delivers the perfect blend of charm, comfort, and breathtaking views. Located in northeast Indiana, Pretty Lake is a serene, non ski lake known for peaceful pontoon cruises, refreshing swims, kayaking adventures, and great fishing. Step inside to discover 3 bedrooms, two inviting living spaces, a fully equipped kitchen, and a dining area that walks out to a large deck overlooking the water. A loft with lake views adds extra character and flexibility. With two full bathrooms and a spacious front deck designed for relaxing or entertaining, this home is ready for your lake life dreams. This retreat includes a secure fenced area so your furry friend can relax and experience lake life right alongside you. This property includes a private aluminum dock that stays with the home, so youll be lake-ready from day one, just bring your boat and let the adventures begin