55 properties for sale in Shelter Island

9 Locust Woods Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 2,995,000
USD 777/sq.ft
9 Locust Woods Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 3,853 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 3 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 3,853 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 3 Baths · House
Welcome to Shelter Island. A place where time slows down and nature takes center stage. Accessible only by ferry, this rare island community offers a level of peace, privacy, and authenticity that is nearly impossible to find in today
Welcome to Shelter Island. A place where time slows down and nature takes center stage. Accessible only by ferry, this rare island community offers a level of peace, privacy, and authenticity that is nearly impossible to find in today
USD 2,995,000
4 Irene Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 1,850,000
USD 713/sq.ft
4 Irene Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 2,594 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 3 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 2,594 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 3 Baths · House
Discover a serene sanctuary amidst the natural beauty of Shelter Island. This stunning residence offers breathtaking water views of Miss Annie
Discover a serene sanctuary amidst the natural beauty of Shelter Island. This stunning residence offers breathtaking water views of Miss Annie
USD 1,850,000
11 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
View photo
House · for sale
USD 2,200,000
USD 1,104/sq.ft
11 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
Shelter Island
· 1,991 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 1,991 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
Shelter Island Heights Icon Gracefully positioned in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this timeless residence has been thoughtfully renovated and restored to honor its original character while seamlessly incorporating today
Shelter Island Heights Icon Gracefully positioned in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this timeless residence has been thoughtfully renovated and restored to honor its original character while seamlessly incorporating today
USD 2,200,000
4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11946
View photo
House · for sale
USD 1,999,999
USD 328/sq.ft
4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11946
Shelter Island
· 6,092 sq.ft · 6 Bedrooms · 5 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 6,092 sq.ft · 6 Bedrooms · 5 Baths · House
Welcome to 4 Bayview Avenue, a remarkable residence nestled in the historic heart of Shelter Island Heights. This expansive property, designed with the art of entertaining in mind, offers a generous six bedrooms and five and a half bathrooms, providing an abundance of space for comfortable living. Upon entering, you
Welcome to 4 Bayview Avenue, a remarkable residence nestled in the historic heart of Shelter Island Heights. This expansive property, designed with the art of entertaining in mind, offers a generous six bedrooms and five and a half bathrooms, providing an abundance of space for comfortable living. Upon entering, you
USD 1,999,999
169 N Ferry Road
View photo
House · for sale
USD 4,250,000
USD 1,214/sq.ft
169 N Ferry Road
Shelter Island
· 3,498 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
· Equipped kitchen · Swimming pool
Shelter Island · 3,498 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House · Equipped kitchen · Swimming pool
There are new homes, and then there is this. A turnkey Bartilucci Construction design-build masterpiece, styled by Heiberg Cummings tucked just outside the heart of Shelter Island Heights. No detail left to chance and no corner cut. What sets this location apart is the rare balance it strikes. Total privacy paired with true convenience. The Heights business district, morning coffee, boutique shopping and art galleries are all just a short stroll away, and the North Ferry is a mere 3 minute drive from your door. Inside, soaring cathedral ceilings that draw the eye straight through to the heated gunite pool beyond. The kitchen is a showpiece. Custom white oak cabinetry, dramatic Taj Mahal countertops, a butler's pantry with its own sink and refrigerator. The primary suite is a true retreat, with spa inspired finishes in the same white oak and Carrara marble found throughout, anchored by a showstopping Carrara marble vessel sink. Outside, the 20x40 heated gunite pool with bluestone coping
There are new homes, and then there is this. A turnkey Bartilucci Construction design-build masterpiece, styled by Heiberg Cummings tucked just outside the heart of Shelter Island Heights. No detail left to chance and no corner cut. What sets this location apart is the rare balance it strikes. Total privacy paired with true convenience. The Heights business district, morning coffee, boutique shopping and art galleries are all just a short stroll away, and the North Ferry is a mere 3 minute drive from your door. Inside, soaring cathedral ceilings that draw the eye straight through to the heated gunite pool beyond. The kitchen is a showpiece. Custom white oak cabinetry, dramatic Taj Mahal countertops, a butler's pantry with its own sink and refrigerator. The primary suite is a true retreat, with spa inspired finishes in the same white oak and Carrara marble found throughout, anchored by a showstopping Carrara marble vessel sink. Outside, the 20x40 heated gunite pool with bluestone coping
USD 4,250,000
12 Terry Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 2,800,000
USD 666/sq.ft
12 Terry Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 4,198 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 4,198 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
Located in the desirable Harborview area of Shelter Island, this modern farmhouse blends luxury, comfort, and coastal living. Just 0.2 miles from a private waterfront association, enjoy easy access to kayaking and the beach. Set on a beautifully landscaped half acre, the home is designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living. The open-concept interior is flooded with natural light, featuring a chef
Located in the desirable Harborview area of Shelter Island, this modern farmhouse blends luxury, comfort, and coastal living. Just 0.2 miles from a private waterfront association, enjoy easy access to kayaking and the beach. Set on a beautifully landscaped half acre, the home is designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living. The open-concept interior is flooded with natural light, featuring a chef
USD 2,800,000
169 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965
View photo
House · for sale
Request Details
169 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965
Shelter Island
· 3,498 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
· Equipped kitchen · Swimming pool
Shelter Island · 3,498 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House · Equipped kitchen · Swimming pool
There are new homes, and then there is this. A turnkey Bartilucci Construction design-build masterpiece, styled by Heiberg Cummings tucked just outside the heart of Shelter Island Heights. No detail left to chance and no corner cut. What sets this location apart is the rare balance it strikes. Total privacy paired with true convenience. The Heights business district, morning coffee, boutique shopping and art galleries are all just a short stroll away, and the North Ferry is a mere 3 minute drive from your door. Inside, soaring cathedral ceilings that draw the eye straight through to the heated gunite pool beyond. The kitchen is a showpiece. Custom white oak cabinetry, dramatic Taj Mahal countertops, a butler
There are new homes, and then there is this. A turnkey Bartilucci Construction design-build masterpiece, styled by Heiberg Cummings tucked just outside the heart of Shelter Island Heights. No detail left to chance and no corner cut. What sets this location apart is the rare balance it strikes. Total privacy paired with true convenience. The Heights business district, morning coffee, boutique shopping and art galleries are all just a short stroll away, and the North Ferry is a mere 3 minute drive from your door. Inside, soaring cathedral ceilings that draw the eye straight through to the heated gunite pool beyond. The kitchen is a showpiece. Custom white oak cabinetry, dramatic Taj Mahal countertops, a butler
Request Details
7 Wheeler Road
View photo
House · for sale
USD 2,690,000
USD 1,178/sq.ft
7 Wheeler Road
Shelter Island
· 2,282 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
· Equipped kitchen
Shelter Island · 2,282 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House · Equipped kitchen
Shelter Island Waterfront with Dock. A rare opportunity to own waterfront in Silver Beach, one of Shelter Island’s most beautiful and sought-after enclaves. Set directly on the tranquil Silver Beach lagoon, this four-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers approximately 2,289 square feet on a private. 76-acre property with approximately 102 feet of waterfront frontage—all just a five-minute walk to beautiful Silver Beach. The home has a distinctive character, combining comfortable interiors, hardwood floors and an abundance of natural light with wonderful water and landscape views from both levels. The kitchen and baths are fully functional and well maintained, while the home’s more traditional finishes offer an opportunity for a new owner to update and personalize the style over time. The waterfront setting is the true centerpiece. An expansive lawn framed by mature trees leads to the canal and an approximately 20-foot grandfathered dock with water and electric, creating direct access for boati
Shelter Island Waterfront with Dock. A rare opportunity to own waterfront in Silver Beach, one of Shelter Island’s most beautiful and sought-after enclaves. Set directly on the tranquil Silver Beach lagoon, this four-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers approximately 2,289 square feet on a private. 76-acre property with approximately 102 feet of waterfront frontage—all just a five-minute walk to beautiful Silver Beach. The home has a distinctive character, combining comfortable interiors, hardwood floors and an abundance of natural light with wonderful water and landscape views from both levels. The kitchen and baths are fully functional and well maintained, while the home’s more traditional finishes offer an opportunity for a new owner to update and personalize the style over time. The waterfront setting is the true centerpiece. An expansive lawn framed by mature trees leads to the canal and an approximately 20-foot grandfathered dock with water and electric, creating direct access for boati
USD 2,690,000
17 Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 900,000
USD 971/sq.ft
17 Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 926 sq.ft · 2 Bedrooms · 1 Bath · House
Shelter Island · 926 sq.ft · 2 Bedrooms · 1 Bath · House
Opportunity awaits with this property being sold strictly as-is. The home is currently uninhabitable and will require a full restoration or renovation down to the frame. Interior access is not available. Seller makes no representations regarding the condition or functionality of heat, water, plumbing, electrical, or other systems. Ideal for investors, builders, or buyers looking for a complete rehab project or potential rebuild. Bring your vision and unlock this property
Opportunity awaits with this property being sold strictly as-is. The home is currently uninhabitable and will require a full restoration or renovation down to the frame. Interior access is not available. Seller makes no representations regarding the condition or functionality of heat, water, plumbing, electrical, or other systems. Ideal for investors, builders, or buyers looking for a complete rehab project or potential rebuild. Bring your vision and unlock this property
USD 900,000
64 N Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 2,199,000
USD 833/sq.ft
64 N Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 2,637 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
· Gym · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen · Cellar
Shelter Island · 2,637 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House · Gym · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen · Cellar
A rare turnkey Shelter Island retreat with two distinct homes tucked away on nearly an acre in the heart of Shelter Island, 64A North Midway Road presents a truly unique opportunity to own two homes on one private property. Surrounded by mature trees, expansive lawns, and a picturesque pond next door, this exceptional estate blends privacy, flexibility, and timeless charm. This rare property offers remarkable versatility to fit your lifestyle. The welcoming ranch-style main home offers 1,316 sq ft of comfortable living space with 3 bedrooms and three full bathrooms. A spacious kitchen with abundant cabinetry flows seamlessly into the dining area, creating an inviting setting for everyday living and entertaining. The living room, anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, provides a warm and cozy gathering place throughout the seasons. The 1,000 sq ft finished basement provides outstanding flexibility for additional living space, a recreation room, home gym, workshop or a hobby area. Step ou
A rare turnkey Shelter Island retreat with two distinct homes tucked away on nearly an acre in the heart of Shelter Island, 64A North Midway Road presents a truly unique opportunity to own two homes on one private property. Surrounded by mature trees, expansive lawns, and a picturesque pond next door, this exceptional estate blends privacy, flexibility, and timeless charm. This rare property offers remarkable versatility to fit your lifestyle. The welcoming ranch-style main home offers 1,316 sq ft of comfortable living space with 3 bedrooms and three full bathrooms. A spacious kitchen with abundant cabinetry flows seamlessly into the dining area, creating an inviting setting for everyday living and entertaining. The living room, anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, provides a warm and cozy gathering place throughout the seasons. The 1,000 sq ft finished basement provides outstanding flexibility for additional living space, a recreation room, home gym, workshop or a hobby area. Step ou
USD 2,199,000
64A N Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 2,199,000
USD 833/sq.ft
64A N Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 2,637 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
· Garden · Swimming pool · Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen
Shelter Island · 2,637 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House · Garden · Swimming pool · Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen
A rare turnkey Shelter Island retreat with two distinct homes tucked away on nearly an acre in the heart of Shelter Island, 64A North Midway Road presents a truly unique opportunity to own two homes on one private property. Surrounded by mature trees, expansive lawns, and a picturesque pond next door, this exceptional estate blends privacy, flexibility, and timeless charm. This rare property offers remarkable versatility to fit your lifestyle. The welcoming ranch-style main home offers a comfortable living space with 3 bedrooms and two full bathrooms. A spacious kitchen with abundant cabinetry flows seamlessly into the dining area, creating an inviting setting for everyday living and entertaining. The living room, anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, provides a warm and cozy gathering place throughout the seasons. Step outside to the expansive rear deck, complete with a hot tub overlooking a large, private backyard with room for a pool, an ideal setting for entertaining, relaxing, or
A rare turnkey Shelter Island retreat with two distinct homes tucked away on nearly an acre in the heart of Shelter Island, 64A North Midway Road presents a truly unique opportunity to own two homes on one private property. Surrounded by mature trees, expansive lawns, and a picturesque pond next door, this exceptional estate blends privacy, flexibility, and timeless charm. This rare property offers remarkable versatility to fit your lifestyle. The welcoming ranch-style main home offers a comfortable living space with 3 bedrooms and two full bathrooms. A spacious kitchen with abundant cabinetry flows seamlessly into the dining area, creating an inviting setting for everyday living and entertaining. The living room, anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, provides a warm and cozy gathering place throughout the seasons. Step outside to the expansive rear deck, complete with a hot tub overlooking a large, private backyard with room for a pool, an ideal setting for entertaining, relaxing, or
USD 2,199,000
22 Locust Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11792
View photo
House · for sale
USD 8,900,000
USD 1,219/sq.ft
22 Locust Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11792
Shelter Island
· 7,298 sq.ft · 6 Bedrooms · 7 Baths · House
· Parking · Swimming pool
Shelter Island · 7,298 sq.ft · 6 Bedrooms · 7 Baths · House · Parking · Swimming pool
Rarely available in an enviable location directly across from the water with mooring rights, this new construction home in Dering Harbor delivers the best of Hamptons living on Shelter Island, ready for immediate enjoyment and for generations to come. Built in 2026 and sited on 2.4 acres, the new construction property has 7,300 +/. SF of interior living space (including the finished lower level) in the house and another 810 SF of living space over the garage, 6 bedrooms, 7 full and 2 half baths, a heated gunite pool and spa, a 2-car garage with finished space above, and a pool pavilion with all of the bells and whistles. Water views, natural light, and bay breezes envelope the gorgeous grounds, while beautiful traditional architecture and expertly manicured landscaping create an exceptional sense of arrival. Clad in cedar-shake siding, the home features elegant columns and expansive shiplap accents. Inside, gorgeous hardwood floors extend across a bright, open main level, where a tradi
Rarely available in an enviable location directly across from the water with mooring rights, this new construction home in Dering Harbor delivers the best of Hamptons living on Shelter Island, ready for immediate enjoyment and for generations to come. Built in 2026 and sited on 2.4 acres, the new construction property has 7,300 +/. SF of interior living space (including the finished lower level) in the house and another 810 SF of living space over the garage, 6 bedrooms, 7 full and 2 half baths, a heated gunite pool and spa, a 2-car garage with finished space above, and a pool pavilion with all of the bells and whistles. Water views, natural light, and bay breezes envelope the gorgeous grounds, while beautiful traditional architecture and expertly manicured landscaping create an exceptional sense of arrival. Clad in cedar-shake siding, the home features elegant columns and expansive shiplap accents. Inside, gorgeous hardwood floors extend across a bright, open main level, where a tradi
USD 8,900,000
11 Jaspa Road
View photo
House · for sale
USD 1,250,000
USD 853/sq.ft
11 Jaspa Road
Shelter Island
· 1,464 sq.ft · 2 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
· Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen
Shelter Island · 1,464 sq.ft · 2 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House · Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen
Welcome to your private Shelter Island retreat, where comfort, character, privacy, and exceptional outdoor living come together. This inviting 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers thoughtfully designed spaces, beautiful hardwood flooring throughout, and an impressive collection of amenities for year-round living or the perfect island escape. The well-appointed kitchen features a refrigerator, dishwasher, built-in microwave, garbage compactor, kitchen-sink water filtration, and plenty of space for everyday cooking and entertaining. The adjoining living room is warm and welcoming with a gas fireplace, while an impressive 12-foot sliding glass door opens onto the expansive deck, creating a wonderful flow between indoor and outdoor living. The deck features a complete grilling station with its own sink and refrigerator, perfect for entertaining family and friends. The showpiece of the home is the extraordinary 17' x 24' primary suite. High ceilings and skylights create a bright, airy atmosphere,
Welcome to your private Shelter Island retreat, where comfort, character, privacy, and exceptional outdoor living come together. This inviting 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers thoughtfully designed spaces, beautiful hardwood flooring throughout, and an impressive collection of amenities for year-round living or the perfect island escape. The well-appointed kitchen features a refrigerator, dishwasher, built-in microwave, garbage compactor, kitchen-sink water filtration, and plenty of space for everyday cooking and entertaining. The adjoining living room is warm and welcoming with a gas fireplace, while an impressive 12-foot sliding glass door opens onto the expansive deck, creating a wonderful flow between indoor and outdoor living. The deck features a complete grilling station with its own sink and refrigerator, perfect for entertaining family and friends. The showpiece of the home is the extraordinary 17' x 24' primary suite. High ceilings and skylights create a bright, airy atmosphere,
USD 1,250,000
7 Wheeler Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965
View photo
House · for sale
USD 2,690,000
USD 1,178/sq.ft
7 Wheeler Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965
Shelter Island
· 2,282 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 2,282 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
Shelter Island Waterfront with Dock. A rare opportunity to own waterfront in Silver Beach, one of Shelter Island
Shelter Island Waterfront with Dock. A rare opportunity to own waterfront in Silver Beach, one of Shelter Island
USD 2,690,000
43 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 3,290,000
USD 539/sq.ft
43 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 6,103 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 6,103 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
Nestled in the highly coveted Hay Beach enclave of Shelter Island, 43 Gardiners Bay Drive is a grand, 6,100-square-foot coastal estate that redefines luxury through the lens of effortless living. Set on a sprawling 0.92-acre parcel with captivating winter water views of Gardiners Bay, this masterfully designed home offers a seamless daily rhythm, beginning in the light-filled foyer where exquisite millwork meets glass doors that open to the expansive grounds. Designed for both high-end entertaining and absolute ease, the flowing main level connects a stately firelit living room to a magnificent chef
Nestled in the highly coveted Hay Beach enclave of Shelter Island, 43 Gardiners Bay Drive is a grand, 6,100-square-foot coastal estate that redefines luxury through the lens of effortless living. Set on a sprawling 0.92-acre parcel with captivating winter water views of Gardiners Bay, this masterfully designed home offers a seamless daily rhythm, beginning in the light-filled foyer where exquisite millwork meets glass doors that open to the expansive grounds. Designed for both high-end entertaining and absolute ease, the flowing main level connects a stately firelit living room to a magnificent chef
USD 3,290,000
140 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 4,800,000
USD 1,376/sq.ft
140 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 3,488 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 3,488 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
Down a private driveway just outside the Heights on approximately 2.3 acres, beside a preserved 4.9 acre meadow, stands
Down a private driveway just outside the Heights on approximately 2.3 acres, beside a preserved 4.9 acre meadow, stands
USD 4,800,000
17 Brander Parkway
View photo
House · for sale
USD 900,000
USD 971/sq.ft
17 Brander Parkway
Shelter Island
· 926 sq.ft · 2 Bedrooms · 1 Bath · House
Shelter Island · 926 sq.ft · 2 Bedrooms · 1 Bath · House
Opportunity awaits with this property being sold strictly as-is. The home is currently uninhabitable and will require a full restoration or renovation down to the frame. Interior access is not available. Seller makes no representations regarding the condition or functionality of heat, water, plumbing, electrical, or other systems. Ideal for investors, builders, or buyers looking for a complete rehab project or potential rebuild. Bring your vision and unlock this property’s full potential. Construction-to-permanent financing options may be available for qualified buyers
Opportunity awaits with this property being sold strictly as-is. The home is currently uninhabitable and will require a full restoration or renovation down to the frame. Interior access is not available. Seller makes no representations regarding the condition or functionality of heat, water, plumbing, electrical, or other systems. Ideal for investors, builders, or buyers looking for a complete rehab project or potential rebuild. Bring your vision and unlock this property’s full potential. Construction-to-permanent financing options may be available for qualified buyers
USD 900,000
11 Jaspa Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 1,250,000
USD 853/sq.ft
11 Jaspa Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 1,464 sq.ft · 2 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
· Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen
Shelter Island · 1,464 sq.ft · 2 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House · Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen
Welcome to your private Shelter Island retreat, where comfort, character, privacy, and exceptional outdoor living come together. This inviting 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers thoughtfully designed spaces, beautiful hardwood flooring throughout, and an impressive collection of amenities for year-round living or the perfect island escape. The well-appointed kitchen features a refrigerator, dishwasher, built-in microwave, garbage compactor, kitchen-sink water filtration, and plenty of space for everyday cooking and entertaining. The adjoining living room is warm and welcoming with a gas fireplace, while an impressive 12-foot sliding glass door opens onto the expansive deck, creating a wonderful flow between indoor and outdoor living. The deck features a complete grilling station with its own sink and refrigerator, perfect for entertaining family and friends. The showpiece of the home is the extraordinary 17
Welcome to your private Shelter Island retreat, where comfort, character, privacy, and exceptional outdoor living come together. This inviting 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers thoughtfully designed spaces, beautiful hardwood flooring throughout, and an impressive collection of amenities for year-round living or the perfect island escape. The well-appointed kitchen features a refrigerator, dishwasher, built-in microwave, garbage compactor, kitchen-sink water filtration, and plenty of space for everyday cooking and entertaining. The adjoining living room is warm and welcoming with a gas fireplace, while an impressive 12-foot sliding glass door opens onto the expansive deck, creating a wonderful flow between indoor and outdoor living. The deck features a complete grilling station with its own sink and refrigerator, perfect for entertaining family and friends. The showpiece of the home is the extraordinary 17
USD 1,250,000
3 Osprey Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 845,000
USD 946/sq.ft
3 Osprey Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 893 sq.ft · 3 Bedrooms · 1 Bath · House
Shelter Island · 893 sq.ft · 3 Bedrooms · 1 Bath · House
This mid-century bungalow is nestled among mature trees, is an opportunity to either renovate or build a new house of your liking
This mid-century bungalow is nestled among mature trees, is an opportunity to either renovate or build a new house of your liking
USD 845,000
15 Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 4,800,000
15 Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Baths · House
Set along the tranquil shores of Menantic Creek, this extraordinary 2.9-acre waterfront offering presents a truly rare opportunity to own a multi-generational compound comprised of two separate parcels, thoughtfully assembled into one remarkable estate. Surrounded by natural beauty and commanding picturesque creek views, the property offers unmatched waterfront living, with over 100ft of water frontage collectively, in one of Shelter Island
Set along the tranquil shores of Menantic Creek, this extraordinary 2.9-acre waterfront offering presents a truly rare opportunity to own a multi-generational compound comprised of two separate parcels, thoughtfully assembled into one remarkable estate. Surrounded by natural beauty and commanding picturesque creek views, the property offers unmatched waterfront living, with over 100ft of water frontage collectively, in one of Shelter Island
USD 4,800,000
5 Marc, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 1,999,999
USD 723/sq.ft
5 Marc, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 2,766 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 3 Baths · House
· Office room · Balcony · Equipped kitchen
Shelter Island · 2,766 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 3 Baths · House · Office room · Balcony · Equipped kitchen
Welcome to your dream getaway where modern luxury meets laid-back coastal charm. This Home is being renovated and there is till time for you to pick your colors. This 4 Bedroom 3.5 Bathroom home offers perfect blend of style u0026 tranquility, just moments from beaches, marinas and all that island has to offer. Designer Kitchen with Quartz countertops. Custom soft close cabinetry with center island u0026 high end appliances. Located on first floor Primary Bedroom with en-suite, cathedral ceiling and french doors to balcony. 3 additional Bedrooms each with an en-suite. Sunken Den, Sitting Room u0026 office. 5
Welcome to your dream getaway where modern luxury meets laid-back coastal charm. This Home is being renovated and there is till time for you to pick your colors. This 4 Bedroom 3.5 Bathroom home offers perfect blend of style u0026 tranquility, just moments from beaches, marinas and all that island has to offer. Designer Kitchen with Quartz countertops. Custom soft close cabinetry with center island u0026 high end appliances. Located on first floor Primary Bedroom with en-suite, cathedral ceiling and french doors to balcony. 3 additional Bedrooms each with an en-suite. Sunken Den, Sitting Room u0026 office. 5
USD 1,999,999
90 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 5,564,640
USD 1,678/sq.ft
90 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 3,315 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 3 Baths · House
Shelter Island · 3,315 sq.ft · 5 Bedrooms · 3 Baths · House
Held by a single family for nearly a century, 90 Peconic Avenue carries the kind of history that can
Held by a single family for nearly a century, 90 Peconic Avenue carries the kind of history that can
USD 5,564,640
14 Crescent Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 1,950,000
USD 637/sq.ft
14 Crescent Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 3,057 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
· Garden · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen · Parking
Shelter Island · 3,057 sq.ft · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House · Garden · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen · Parking
Open the gates and enter a gracious center hall colonial set on a shy acre, framed by established trees, hydrangeas, and thoughtfully designed perennial gardens. Built in 2003, the home offers just over 3,000 square feet of generously proportioned living space. The front foyer introduces a traditional floor plan with glass doors opening to a library on the left and a formal living room on the right. The living room flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, creating an elegant progression from the front to the rear of the home. At the heart of the residence, the kitchen is well positioned between the dining room and an impressive great room. Double-height ceilings, wood burning fireplace, second-floor overlook, and a dramatic wall of windows fill the space with natural light while framing views of the gardens beyond. Discreetly tucked behind the great room are a powder room, pantry and utility storage, laundry room, and interior access to an oversized two-car garage. The second floo
Open the gates and enter a gracious center hall colonial set on a shy acre, framed by established trees, hydrangeas, and thoughtfully designed perennial gardens. Built in 2003, the home offers just over 3,000 square feet of generously proportioned living space. The front foyer introduces a traditional floor plan with glass doors opening to a library on the left and a formal living room on the right. The living room flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, creating an elegant progression from the front to the rear of the home. At the heart of the residence, the kitchen is well positioned between the dining room and an impressive great room. Double-height ceilings, wood burning fireplace, second-floor overlook, and a dramatic wall of windows fill the space with natural light while framing views of the gardens beyond. Discreetly tucked behind the great room are a powder room, pantry and utility storage, laundry room, and interior access to an oversized two-car garage. The second floo
USD 1,950,000
15 N Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964
View photo
House · for sale
USD 1,445,000
USD 1,032/sq.ft
15 N Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island
· 1,399 sq.ft · 3 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
· Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen · Parking
Shelter Island · 1,399 sq.ft · 3 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House · Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen · Parking
Located around the corner from a sandy beach, this cedar. Shingled cottage has had recent renovations. Step inside the entry foyer and to the right is a marvelous, open-plan space with cathedral ceilings. The living area has a bay window to the front of the home and a fireplace. Immediately adjacent is the kitchen with cherry cabinets, granite counters and recently installed appliances, with an adjacent dining area. A screened porch just off the dining area is one of the most popular spaces, an outdoor room with entertainment deck. There are two guest bedrooms with a hall bathroom, as well as a primary en-suite bedroom. The grounds are beautifully landscaped and there is a delightful outdoor shower. An oversized attached two-car garage. Property taxes per annum as of 2025 are $6,656
Located around the corner from a sandy beach, this cedar. Shingled cottage has had recent renovations. Step inside the entry foyer and to the right is a marvelous, open-plan space with cathedral ceilings. The living area has a bay window to the front of the home and a fireplace. Immediately adjacent is the kitchen with cherry cabinets, granite counters and recently installed appliances, with an adjacent dining area. A screened porch just off the dining area is one of the most popular spaces, an outdoor room with entertainment deck. There are two guest bedrooms with a hall bathroom, as well as a primary en-suite bedroom. The grounds are beautifully landscaped and there is a delightful outdoor shower. An oversized attached two-car garage. Property taxes per annum as of 2025 are $6,656
USD 1,445,000
2 Quail Run
View photo
House · for sale
USD 2,495,000
USD 1,125/sq.ft
2 Quail Run
Shelter Island
· 2,217 sq.ft · 3 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House
· Garden · Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen · Swimming pool
Shelter Island · 2,217 sq.ft · 3 Bedrooms · 2 Baths · House · Garden · Deck · Fireplace · Equipped kitchen · Swimming pool
Beautifully and meticulously maintained, this traditional 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath turnkey home is tucked away on a very quiet street, surrounded by lovely landscaping and offering a wonderful sense of privacy. Inside, a beautifully renovated kitchen with high-end appliances flows into an inviting open floor plan, creating a warm and welcoming setting for everyday living and entertaining. The inviting primary suite opens onto a screened-in porch and wraparound deck, offering a lovely connection to the outdoors. A fireplace adds warmth and charm, while outside, a completely fenced-in yard features a beautiful new Gunite pool and a cozy fire pit with surrounding seating, perfect for gathering with family and friends. Ideally located near Wade’s Beach, Fresh Pond, and the South Ferry, the gateway to the Hamptons, this special property offers the best of Shelter Island living, with comfort, privacy, and convenience all in one
Beautifully and meticulously maintained, this traditional 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath turnkey home is tucked away on a very quiet street, surrounded by lovely landscaping and offering a wonderful sense of privacy. Inside, a beautifully renovated kitchen with high-end appliances flows into an inviting open floor plan, creating a warm and welcoming setting for everyday living and entertaining. The inviting primary suite opens onto a screened-in porch and wraparound deck, offering a lovely connection to the outdoors. A fireplace adds warmth and charm, while outside, a completely fenced-in yard features a beautiful new Gunite pool and a cozy fire pit with surrounding seating, perfect for gathering with family and friends. Ideally located near Wade’s Beach, Fresh Pond, and the South Ferry, the gateway to the Hamptons, this special property offers the best of Shelter Island living, with comfort, privacy, and convenience all in one
USD 2,495,000

Get email alerts

Don't miss out: be the first to know about new properties

The alert was correctly created

On subscribing you accept the conditions of use and the privacy policy
Alert
Receive new ads in your inbox
Save this search
Receive alerts for new listings

We'll send you an email when we have new properties for: "Properties for sale in Shelter Island"

The alert was correctly created

Get email alerts and be the first to see new listings
Required field
On subscribing I accept the terms of the privacy policy
Perfect! You'll soon start receiving new listings via email
Alert
Receive an email when we have new ads for Properties for sale in Shelter Island
Save this search
Filters

Bedrooms

Size (sq.ft)

sq.ft
sq.ft

Price

USD
USD

Property type

Bathrooms

Clear all filters
Receive notifications when new entries are published.