63 properties for sale in Prendergast Point

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

Discover a hidden Chautauqua Lake waterfront retreat tucked away on a private drive and nestled below a peaceful wooded hillside, creating an exceptional sense of privacy and arrival. Two private driveways provide ample parking. Park at the upper drive and follow the staircase through a beautiful wooded setting to this extraordinary lakefront escape. The property features two separate homes, 130 feet of waterfront, deeded water rights, dock, boat hoist, private beach access, an inground pool, spa, and panoramic lake views. The main home offers five bedrooms and two full baths, a spacious eat in kitchen, inviting living room with a wood burning fireplace, dining room, and a stunning morning room overlooking the lake. A one of a kind bunk room with four built in beds and two trundle beds provides an unforgettable space for hosting family and guests. Unwind on the covered porch while taking in the breathtaking waterfront views. The separate guest house features an open concept design with

Calling all investors & builders! Sitting on 1.7 acres and in the heart of the village of Bemus Point abundant opportunities await on this 19 Unit apartment complex (Formally Maple Grove School). Many recent updates include Boiler replacement in 2024, all new windows, new exterior doors, new mini-split heating and cooling, new breakers and panels in every apartment, some new appliances all of which was completed in 2025. This property is steps from Chautauqua Lake with rooftop views of the lake as well as Bemus point Golf Coarse. Great potential for development! The gymnasium, basement and stage has additional square footage for expansion. This is a unique opportunity that to take advantage of all Bemus has to offer

Charming year-round 3-bedroom, 1-bath home in desirable Oriental Park, Bemus Point! Just one block from Chautauqua Lake with lake access through the Oriental Allotment, this well-maintained home offers the perfect mix of comfort, updates, and location. Enjoy walking to Bemus Point, golfing nearby, and snowmobiling right from your driveway. Features include laundry, a metal roof, many updates, and two sheds—one insulated and ready to be finished as a cozy sleeping hut, playhouse, or extra hangout space. Outdoor living shines with a deck, patio, landscaped yard, and plenty of space to relax or entertain. A great year-round home or lake-area getaway!

Bemus Point Area 89 ACRE SPREAD with a HUGE Original Farmhouse. 1,659 Feet of Road frontage with subdivision potential. The Acreage is +/. 1/3rd Tillable Hay fields with WOODLANDS and Mixed Habitat on the balance. Proven Deer Hunting success with Trails to Stand locations and Food Plots. There is a 25 foot owned unused Farm Lane from the westerly side road (Bayview Rd). The Local Sled Trail crosses the Rear SW Corner of the property. The home has 3,258 square feet, with 5 bedrooms, 3 Baths, and two second floor stairwells. The Layout is typical Farmhouse with formal dining, living rooms, and dens. The Home has original features and is DATED with paneling, carpeting. Awaiting your new Vision. A New (2025) white metal roof with soffits/facia and new main electric line/panel installed. The newer (2020) Garage/Shop is 32x48x14 and fully Insulated. Concrete floor with drain-Two overhead 60k propane heaters, and a wood furnace with an 8 foot fan and LED Lighting. Two 12x12 Overhead Doors wit

Welcome to 5098 W. Lake Road in Mayville, a tucked-away hidden gem the sellers lovingly describe as their “Lakeside Secret Garden. ” Set in a peaceful, private-feeling setting close to Chautauqua Institution, this charming home offers over 2,280 square feet of comfortable living space with beautiful lake views and deeded lake rights, including a dock and boat slip. Inside, you’ll find hardwood floors, a warm and inviting living area with a wood-burning fireplace, gorgeous built-ins and a spacious kitchen complete with a walk-in pantry. The flexible layout features 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths, with a bathroom conveniently located on each floor, plus a den/office space with a lake-facing window. A walk-up attic provides excellent storage, while the walk-out partially finished basement offers even more usable space with a mudroom, laundry area, bonus space currently used as a gym, and an additional full bath. Recent updates include a new roof, windows, and first-floor bathroom remodel in

Charming 2-bedroom year-round cottage in the heart of Bemus Point with deeded lake rights through the Oriental Park Allotment and lake access at the end of the street. This well-maintained home features insulated windows, an updated bathroom, updated plumbing and electrical, and on-demand hot water. Enjoy the private backyard with a new deck and Jamestown awning—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Conveniently located close to the village, shopping, restaurants, golf, lake activities, and more. A wonderful place to vacation, live year-round, snowmobile, ski, and enjoy everything Bemus Point has to offer!

Picture perfect 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home located in the Bemus Point School District — and it offers far more than what meets the eye. Step inside to a pristine, sun-filled living room that flows seamlessly into an open dining and kitchen area, perfect for entertaining! The main level is designed for true convenience with one-floor amenities including a bedroom, full bath, and laundry — ideal for easy everyday living. Two additional standout spaces round out the first floor: a rear family room anchored by a cozy gas fireplace, and a heated sunporch with double doors that invite the outside in. Open those doors on a warm summer day and feel the breeze rolling off nearby Chautauqua Lake — it's pure magic. Upstairs, two generously sized bedrooms, a full bathroom, and ample storage closets provide comfortable, private space for family or guests. Step outside to a beautifully landscaped yard built for both function and relaxation. A 2-car garage with an attached workshop, while a dedicated

Introducing 188 South Erie Street, a landmark waterfront opportunity along the shores of Chautauqua Lake offering over 5,000 square feet of mixed-use space with extraordinary residential, hospitality, and commercial potential. Formerly home to one of the area’s most recognized lakefront destinations, the property is now positioned to offer a rare opportunity for an owner, investor, or visionary entrepreneur to write this iconic property’s next chapter. Inside, soaring ceilings, dramatic architectural trusses, expansive open-concept interiors, and panoramic lake views create an atmosphere unlike anything else on the lake. Originally designed for gathering and entertaining on a grand scale, the existing layout naturally lends itself to a luxury waterfront residence, boutique hospitality concept, mixed-use development, or a wide range of commercial and lifestyle-oriented ventures. Existing infrastructure includes a commercial kitchen layout, large central bar, expansive waterfront patios,

Experience easy lakefront living here on the'Gold Coast” at 190 Lakeside Dr. In Bemus Pt. NY. Perfectly positioned on the hillside, you’ll enjoy sweeping views of Chautauqua Lake with direct lake access. Highlights include upper and lower decks, large private yard plus a private dock with 100’ of lake frontage. Step outside and it’s a short stroll to the Village, where you’ll find ample dining options, shopping destinations, and summertime entertainment. This stunning home is ready for you to enjoy as a summer retreat or as an inviting year round residence. With 4 BR & 4 BA and generous gathering spaces, this thoughtfully designed home lends itself to entertaining or simply relaxing while taking in unforgettable sunsets and star-filled skies! The main floor features an open concept living and dining area with soaring cathedral ceilings and oversized windows capturing lake views from every angle. With two sets of sliding glass doors, experience easy indoor-outdoor flow with direct acces

Located in desirable Bemus Point on beautiful Chautauqua Lake, this charming year-round lakefront cottage offers the perfect blend of comfort, character, and waterfront living. Situated on two lots with 35 feet of lake frontage, this property features 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and beautiful outdoor spaces designed to enjoy lake life to the fullest. Inside, you’ll find an inviting open floor plan where the kitchen flows seamlessly into the living room, creating a bright and welcoming atmosphere for everyday living or entertaining guests. The home features low-maintenance vinyl siding, laminate flooring, and some wall-to-wall carpeting for added comfort. Step outside to a spacious deck and stone patio overlooking the water—ideal for morning coffee, summer gatherings, or simply taking in the peaceful lake views. A major bonus is the detached heated garage featuring radiant heat in the concrete floors, making it a comfortable and versatile space for multiple uses such as vehicle storage, a

Welcome to 21 Academy Street in the charming Village of Mayville! This well-maintained 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home blends classic character with modern updates and everyday comfort. Offering approximately 1,300 square feet of living space on a spacious lot, this property provides room to relax both inside and out. Inside, you'll find a functional layout featuring a beautifully updated kitchen complete with stainless steel appliances, ample cabinet space, and a bright, inviting atmosphere perfect for daily living and entertaining. The home's bathrooms have also been tastefully updated, adding style and convenience throughout. First-floor laundry makes household chores a breeze and adds to the home's practical appeal. The comfortable living spaces and well-sized bedrooms offer flexibility for a variety of lifestyles, while the home's thoughtful updates allow you to move right in and start enjoying all it has to offer. Just off the dining room, a covered porch provides the perfect spot to en

Welcome to your perfect getaway on beautiful Chautauqua Lake! This inviting home offers the ideal blend of comfort, scenic views, and year-round enjoyment. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat, a vacation property, or a full-time residence, this property delivers. Step inside to find a warm and welcoming interior filled with natural light. The spacious living area is perfect for relaxing after a day on the water, while the well-appointed kitchen provides ample space for cooking and entertaining. Large windows frame picturesque lake views, bringing the outdoors in. The property offers easy access to the water, perfect for boating, fishing, or simply enjoying the tranquil setting. Included in this sale will be the dock and boat to enjoy all of these activities. Located just minutes from the village of Mayville, you’ll have convenient access to local shops, dining, and year-round events, while still enjoying the peace and privacy of lakeside living. Don’t miss this opportunity to

Welcome to the'Sunnyside' of life here in this adorable and versatile home nestled in the heart of Bemus Point on beautiful Chautauqua Lake. This meticulous home features 1 bedroom plus a flexible bonus space perfect for additional sleeping quarters, a loft, or a studio. This home is ideal for those seeking comfort, character, and convenience. Inside, you’ll find an updated kitchen with modern appliances and a cozy eat-in area, seamlessly flowing into a combination living and dining room—perfect for everyday living or entertaining. Bamboo flooring adds warmth and style throughout, while two full bathrooms provide added functionality. The loft area is a true highlight, featuring a gas fireplace and charming built-in nooks originally designed for yarn storage—now ready for your creative touch. This home has been thoughtfully maintained with a new furnace, newer hot water tank, and updated windows, all complemented by a low-maintenance vinyl exterior. Outside, enjoy a manageable yard with

Welcome to 3949/3- South Nesmith in Bemus Point! This property has 2 parcels containing a 3 bedroom, 1 bath, 1280 square foot fully funished home with a detached 2 car garage. As you enter the driveway, there is a cozy concrete covered patio that welcomes you, perfect for morning coffee or afternoon reading. Inside the rear door, there is an open foyer with brick flooring. This leads to a large living room with hardwood floors along with modern wall and lighting accents. All 3 tastefully decorated bedrooms have hardwood floors and space for clothes. The full bath has tile flooring and a walk in shower. The kitchen and dining area are open and spacious with an island with ample seating, tile flooring and modern appliances. The mechanicals include an electric hot water tank, forced air gas furnace, water softener, circuit breakers and a large side storage room with an exterior door. In addition, the property has an approved space on the lot for a 1500 sq. Foot home that could be built on

Welcome to 9 Maple Street in the heart of Bemus Point — a versatile 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offering endless possibilities. This property can be enjoyed as a spacious single-family residence or used as a duplex with two separate units, one up and one down. It has most recently operated as a successful 2-unit long-term rental, offering a strong income history, yet can easily be used as a single-family layout for those seeking more space. Another great option is an owner-occupied rental – live in one unit while you rent the other and the rental income can help pay your expenses. The home features beautiful hardwood floors and woodwork throughout. The first floor offers a spacious, updated kitchen with granite countertops, a large living area, a first-floor bedroom, and full bathroom. The partially finished basement adds great bonus space. Upstairs, you’ll find a comfortable living room, a bedroom or home office, a second kitchen, and a full bathroom with laundry. The third floor provi

Wake up to panoramic views of beautiful Chautauqua Lake from this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home. Sip your morning coffee on the private dock, spend sunny afternoons on the water, and cap the day with cozy bonfires under the stars. Perfectly positioned just a few doors down from historic Midway State Park and only a mile from Long Point State Park, you’ll be close to classic family fun, hiking, beaches, and boat launches. Inside, you’ll find comfortable living spaces and lake-facing windows that bring the outdoors in. Come enjoy everything Chautauqua Lake has to offer—relaxation, recreation, and unforgettable sunsets

A private, fenced courtyard filled with colorful flowers and a covered front porch create a warm and inviting welcome. Inside, the open-concept living and dining area features attractive Engineered Hardwood flooring, a cozy gas fireplace, and picturesque lake views that make the space perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The galley-style kitchen features granite countertops, tiled flooring, ample cabinet space, and stainless steel appliances, including a refrigerator, gas range, microwave, and dishwasher. A convenient half bath completes the main level. Upstairs, you'll find two comfortable, carpeted bedrooms and two full bathrooms. The primary bedroom opens to a private balcony overlooking Chautauqua Lake—the perfect spot to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind while taking in the sunset. One of the full bathrooms features a walk-in shower and convenient second-floor laundry, adding everyday ease and functionality. Residents enjoy the ease of HOA-maintained living, with fees that incl

Welcome to 4420 Lakeside Drive, a beautifully designed home that perfectly blends comfort, space, and lakeside charm. Enjoy views of Chautauqua Lake along with deeded lake rights. A covered front porch overlooks the lake, providing a peaceful place to relax and take in the view. Just off the porch is an additional patio with a hot tub, creating the ultimate outdoor retreat for entertaining or unwinding after a long day. Inside, the foyer opens to a spacious living room featuring a gas fireplace, tall ceilings, and abundant natural light. The kitchen and dining area offer an open-concept design with stainless steel appliances, a large island with seating, and generous counter and cabinet space—ideal for cooking, entertaining, or gathering with family. A convenient half bath adds to the home's functionality. The finished basement expands the living space with a large den centered around another gas fireplace, a wet bar, full bathroom, and substantial storage area. This versatile level of

The iconic Red Brick Farm property is located along Route 394 on the well-trafficked N. Lake corridor between Chautauqua Institution and the Village of Mayville. The compound includes seven buildings situated on approximately 25 acres of land. This turn of the century property was originally a dairy farm which the current owner painstakingly converted into a restaurant, living and retail spaces. The House is set up to operate as a restaurant on the main level with living quarters on the second and third floors. Once inside you'll be impressed by the many original architectural details which were preserved including original hardwood floors, mantles, stairwell and pocket doors. This stately brick home is a prominent feature of the property with its wonderful wraparound porch and handsome brick facade. The Barn has been fully reconstructed inside and is a feast for the eyes with its soaring gambrel ceiling and versatile main floor and loft spaces. The Milking Barn and Produce Stand are b

Lakefront Luxury living at Bemus Bay Condominiums in the heart of Bemus Point. This 2nd-floor, 3-bedroom, 2-bath condo offers 1,502 sq ft of single-level living with elevator access. Enjoy 400 feet of gated private lakefront and a valuable inside dock slip—ideal for boating and waterfront living. The unit is meticulously maintained, never rented, and offered furnished. Inside features an open layout connecting kitchen, dining, and living areas, highlighted by a fireplace and private balcony with lake views. The kitchen is finished with quality stainless appliances, while both baths feature stone tile and walk-in showers. Custom built-ins and generous closet space provide excellent storage throughout. Community amenities include a lakeside pool, plus direct lake access. A one-car garage and additional assigned parking complete the package. Walk to restaurants, shops, parks, tennis courts, and more. Just minutes to Chautauqua Institution and year-round recreation. Whether you're looking

Welcome to 4934 Bayview Road in Ellery, NY — a traditional home situated on approximately 17 acres offering space, flexibility, and a peaceful setting. With a classic layout and functional design, this property provides a variety of possibilities both inside and out. The front of the home features a traditional dining room and family room, creating comfortable spaces for everyday living and entertaining. The updated kitchen blends modern convenience with the home’s timeless character. Located just off the kitchen are the first-floor laundry area, full bathroom, spacious office, and first-floor bedroom. The office offers flexible use and could also serve as an additional living area, workspace, hobby room, or guest space, depending on your needs. Upstairs, you’ll find three additional bedrooms offering ample space and versatility. Outside, the approximately 17-acre property provides room to enjoy open space, recreation, gardening, or future possibilities while taking in the surrounding

Welcome to this charming year-round or vacation-ready home located in the heart of Bemus Point. Tucked on a quiet street, Close Proximity to shops, dining, and everyday conveniences. This beautifully updated property offers comfort, convenience, and a true village-living experience. Enjoy the beautiful, covered porch, complete with awnings that allow you to use the space even during cooler months. Step inside to a bright open floorplan connecting the kitchen, dining area, and living room — perfect for everyday living or hosting guests. The interior has been freshly painted throughout, giving the home a crisp, move-in-ready feel. The first floor features a laundry room with folding table, a full bathroom, and access to the new patio and professionally landscaped yard. Upstairs, you’ll find two bedrooms and a full bath, plus a walk-through third bedroom with a privacy curtain — ideal for extra sleeping space or a cozy guest nook. An attached heated garage provides year-round convenience,