28 properties for sale in Toddsville

This is a Real Estate-Owned (REO)/post-foreclosure home owned or managed by a bank. All offers are considered; however, the highest and best will most likely be accepted

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

Welcome to 6208 NY-28 in Fly Creek — a rare mixed-use investment opportunity that perfectly blends small-town charm, modern updates, and immediate business potential. Ideally located just minutes from Cooperstown and the renowned Fly Creek Cider Mill, this highly visible corner property sits in the heart of the hamlet, offering outstanding exposure for business and convenience for residents alike. This impressive building features two commercial spaces and four residential rental units, creating multiple income streams under one roof. The anchor commercial space is currently configured as a fully equipped restaurant and bar, featuring an elegant dining room with tall ceilings, hardwood floors, and large windows that fill the space with natural light. A professional kitchen, handcrafted bar, and outdoor deck create the perfect setting for indoor and seasonal dining. The restaurant space is ready for its next chapter, offering an opportunity for an operator to step in and bring their con

This is a Real Estate-Owned (REO)/post-foreclosure home owned or managed by a bank. All offers are considered; however, the highest and best will most likely be accepted

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This is a Real Estate-Owned (REO)/post-foreclosure home owned or managed by a bank. All offers are considered; however, the highest and best will most likely be accepted

Welcome to 626 County Highway 45, Milford, NY a charming cabin-style retreat nestled in the quiet beauty of Otsego County. Just a short drive from Cooperstown yet far enough to feel like your own peaceful escape, this adorable 2-bedroom, 1bath cabin is perfect for first-time homebuyers, a weekend getaway, or anyone seeking a simpler lifestyle surrounded by nature. Property Highlights- Cozy Interior: Step into an open-concept living area where natural light streams through wooden-framed windows, casting warm tones across hardwood floors. The living room's rustic character with exposed beams and a pellet stove invites you to unwind, read a book, or host intimate gatherings. Functional Kitchen: The kitchen offers clean cabinetry, ample counter space, and room for upgrades. Whether brewing morning coffee or preparing comfort meals, this space delivers practicality and charm. Bedrooms and Bath: Two comfortable bedrooms, both with peaceful wooded views, provide a quiet sanctuary. The full ba

Welcome to 626 County Highway 45, Milford, NY a charming cabin-style retreat nestled in the quiet beauty of Otsego County. Just a short drive from Cooperstown yet far enough to feel like your own peaceful escape, this adorable 2-bedroom, 1bath cabin is perfect for first-time homebuyers, a weekend getaway, or anyone seeking a simpler lifestyle surrounded by nature. Property Highlights- Cozy Interior: Step into an open-concept living area where natural light streams through wooden-framed windows, casting warm tones across hardwood floors. The living room's rustic character with exposed beams and a pellet stove invites you to unwind, read a book, or host intimate gatherings. Functional Kitchen: The kitchen offers clean cabinetry, ample counter space, and room for upgrades. Whether brewing morning coffee or preparing comfort meals, this space delivers practicality and charm. Bedrooms and Bath: Two comfortable bedrooms, both with peaceful wooded views, provide a quiet sanctuary. The full ba

Inspired by Park Avenue. Surrounded by the timeless beauty of Cooperstown. For those who believe a home should be a reflection of art, not simply a place to live. Some homes are built. Others are curated. Privately nestled among the rolling hills just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown, this extraordinary country estate blends timeless architecture, gracious living, and inspired design. Originally conceived by the late Angela Plowden Wardlaw, the home reflects her appreciation for sophisticated interiors and was inspired by legendary New York architect Rosario Candela, whose iconic Park Avenue and Sutton Place residences defined an era of elegant living. The thoughtful floor plan embraces Candela's philosophy of balancing grandeur with warmth, creating spaces equally suited for entertaining and everyday life. A dramatic entrance hall welcomes guests before revealing a graceful winding staircase. The expansive foyer flows into a sun-filled sitting room, while a handsome study and f

Steeped in history yet rebuilt to the highest modern standards, 159 Cat Town Road is a truly exceptional offering. Originally constructed in the 1800s, this home has undergone a meticulous restoration where heritage architecture and advanced building science converge. Every detail has been thoughtfully curated to preserve the character of the original structure while delivering the comfort and efficiency expected in a modern home. Inside, you’ll find a complete transformation with clean lines, warm finishes, new flooring throughout, and custom trim work. The thoughtfully designed layout offers both openness and comfort, highlighted by a beautifully updated kitchen featuring new cabinetry, Corian countertops, a tile backsplash, and LED accent lighting. The primary bath serves as a private retreat with elegant finishes and a tiled shower. Beyond aesthetics, the home delivers remarkable performance and efficiency. Built with advanced double-stud construction and high-performance insulatio

Bryn Brooke Manor — an 1884 American Shingle Style estate designed by acclaimed NYC architects Babb, Cook & Willard for Dr. Robert McKim — sits on nearly 3 acres overlooking Otsego Lake in the heart of Cooperstown. Architectural historian Richard G. Wilson called it one of the finest examples of the Shingle Style country house he had ever seen. From the wraparound porches and two-story turret, views stretch across the lake to the Otesaga Hotel and Leatherstocking Golf Course. The Fenimore Art Museum, Farmers’ Museum, Baseball Hall of Fame, and Main Street’s shops and cafés are all a short walk away. Inside, 70+ windows fill the home with light across butternut, oak, and maple finishes. Five fireplaces anchor the main living spaces, and original details — the split staircase, carved entrance door, turret library — remain intact and beautifully maintained. The 400+ sq. ft. Chef’s kitchen offers multiple workspaces, a gas cooktop, and direct porch access for easy entertaining. Operating s

Huge Price Improvement, Minutes from the Baseball Hall of Fame and nestled in the heart of Cooperstown's Glimmerglass region, 533 Glimmerglen Road is a rare find: a 1999-built Cape Cod on 1.79 acres with the curb appeal of a boutique country estate and the flexibility to serve as a primary residence, seasonal retreat, or high-performing short-term rental in one of upstate New York's strongest tourism markets. Cooperstown draws hundreds of thousands of visitors annually to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Ommegang Brewery, Glimmerglass Opera, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, and Otsego Lake. Quality rental inventory in this radius is consistently tight, and properties with this kind of presentation rarely come available. Inside, the layout rewards flexibility. A primary suite and second bedroom on the main floor provide true single-level living, while the second floor opens additional space for family or guests. Three bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms offer comfortable c

A rare opportunity awaits in the heart of Cooperstown’s historic business district. Situated just steps from Doubleday Field, 127 Main Street offers over 4,200 square feet of versatile mixed-use space, blending retail, office, and residential components with one-of-a-kind outdoor amenities. The first floor features an inviting office or retail space with wood out of Hyde Hall throughout, and bathroom, ideal for a boutique, professional office, or storefront business. The second floor includes a potential office space that has 3 potential offices with a kitchen area break room and a fully upgraded bathroom! On the third floor, a spacious two-bedroom apartment showcases cathedral ceilings and a private back deck overlooking the courtyard and the historic Doubleday Field, providing a rare and beautiful view in the center of the village. The property is approximately 95% renovated, with extensive updates throughout. Recent improvements include new flooring and paint, updated bathrooms with

What makes this classic farmhouse unusual-even among rural properties-is how it sits. Unlike most homes of its era, typically built close to the road, this one is set well back, giving the entire farm compound a sense of privacy and quiet that feels intentional. To the east, a broad hillside rises gently behind the property, creating a natural backdrop that makes the setting feel sheltered rather than exposed. It's the kind of place where you can decompress and reconnect. From the west-facing porch, long evening light stretches across open fields, with unhurried sunsets and expansive skies that are increasingly hard to find. The timber-frame barn is a standout. Built with true post-and-beam craftsmanship, it offers a scale and integrity that's increasingly rare. Its taller-than-typical first-floor ceiling height makes it well suited for horses, events, or creative and agricultural uses that require volume and light. A large fenced area is attached. A 1910 hops barn and a chicken coop w

Village Living at Its Best – Just Moments from Leatherstocking Golf Course Perfectly situated on one of Cooperstown's most desirable tree-lined streets, 46 Nelson Avenue offers the best of Village living. Enjoy an easy walk to the renowned Leatherstocking Golf Course at The Otesaga Resort Hotel, recently recognized by USA TODAY's 10Best as the nation's #2 public golf course for the second consecutive year. You'll also love being just minutes from the Saturday farmers' market, charming boutiques, restaurants, Bassett Hospital and the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Originally built in 1902, this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2-bath Colonial combines timeless character with thoughtful modern updates. Recent improvements include two tastefully renovated bathrooms, refreshed interior finishes, hardwood floors, soapstone kitchen countertops, and newer appliances, creating a home that's ready for you to move right in. The enclosed front porch, wrapped in windows, provides a welcoming pla

Timeless Victorian Charm on a Quiet Village Street Discover the warmth and character of this beautiful 1880 Victorian home, held in the loving care of the same family for over 60 years. Tucked away on a quiet, tree-lined village street, this home offers historic integrity, incredible bones, and the opportunity to update a classic to fit your personal style. The Residence: A Solid Foundation With 4 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this home has been meticulously maintained for over six decades, preserving its classic layout and architectural craftsmanship. Hidden Treasures: Beneath the wool wall-to-wall carpeting lies original hardwood flooring waiting to be uncovered and restored to its full glory. Bring Your Vision: While the home has been impeccably cared for, the kitchen and bathrooms are ready for modern updates, giving you the rare chance to design your dream spaces within a historic framework. A Private Backyard Haven Step outside into a wonderfully private outdoor space, complet

Welcome to 105 Cemetery Road, Fly Creek — an exceptional luxury retreat offering space, privacy, and outstanding income-producing potential. This expansive property features 6 bedrooms, 6 full bathrooms, and 1 half bath across a beautifully designed layout ideal for year-round living, vacation use, or short-term rental investment. Currently utilized as a successful rental property by the sellers, this home presents a rare turnkey opportunity for buyers seeking both lifestyle and revenue potential. From the moment you arrive, the property impresses with its peaceful setting, attractive curb appeal, and resort-style amenities. Inside, you’ll find custom cabinetry, premium countertops, high-end flooring, and thoughtfully designed living spaces throughout. The gourmet kitchen serves as the heart of the home with upscale finishes, abundant prep space, and an open-concept design perfect for entertaining large groups and gatherings. The outdoor living experience is equally impressive, featuri

Remarks: This stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home offers the ultimate lakeside lifestyle in the incredible Cooperstown Village location, just steps from Lakefront Park, the village docks and home of the National Baseball Hall of Fame. The main level features a modern kitchen with granite counter tops and stainless steel appliances and a formal dining room with gleaming hardwood floors. There is a first floor primary ensuite, a mudroom and laundry area along with a powder room. The heart of the home is the vaulted, sun-drenched living room, which boasts cathedral ceilings, skylights, a built-in wine cooler, and a Vermont Castings wood-burning fireplace. The French doors lead out to the back yard with views of Otsego Lake! Moving upstairs, the second floor features a second bedroom and a second full bathroom complete with a soaking tub and walk-in closet, alongside a spacious suite offering its own walk-in closet, space for a home office overlooking the lake, Juliet windows, and skylig

This single family home offers 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms with 2,064 sq ft of living space on almost 5 acres lot, plus a full basement and two mother-in-law suites that provide flexible living space or potential rental opportunities. The kitchen features wooden cabinets, tile countertops, a breakfast bar, island, and LVP flooring. The combined living and dining area includes a fireplace, while the main bedroom offers a walk-in closet, private bath, and window A/C. Outside, the property includes a detached 2-car garage, large rear deck with a covered canopy and gazebo, storage shed. The home is served by well and septic systems and includes a standby propane generator, updated basement drainage system with newer pumps, vinyl siding, and a re-shingled roof

Huge Price Improvement, Minutes from the Baseball Hall of Fame and nestled in the heart of Cooperstown's Glimmerglass region, 533 Glimmerglen Road is a rare find: a 1999-built Cape Cod on 1.79 acres with the curb appeal of a boutique country estate and the flexibility to serve as a primary residence, seasonal retreat, or high-performing short-term rental in one of upstate New York's strongest tourism markets. Cooperstown draws hundreds of thousands of visitors annually to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Ommegang Brewery, Glimmerglass Opera, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, and Otsego Lake. Quality rental inventory in this radius is consistently tight, and properties with this kind of presentation rarely come available. Inside, the layout rewards flexibility. A primary suite and second bedroom on the main floor provide true single-level living, while the second floor opens additional space for family or guests. Three bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms offer comfortable c

What makes this classic farmhouse unusual, even among rural properties, is how it sits. Unlike most of its era, which were built close to the road, this one is set well back — giving the farm a privacy and quiet that feels intentional rather than accidental. To the east, a broad hillside rises behind the property, creating a natural shelter that makes the site feel held rather than exposed. It's a place to decompress and reconnect. The views from the west-facing porch are exactly what you'd hope for — long evening light across open fields, unhurried sunsets, and the kind of sky city life makes you forget. The timber-frame barn is the centerpiece. Its construction is exceptional — true post-and-beam craftsmanship, increasingly rare. A key feature is the taller-than-typical first-floor ceiling height, making it practical for horses and well suited to events, a studio, or agricultural and creative uses needing volume and light. A large fenced area is attached. A 1910 Hops Barn and a chick

Completely renovated and move-in ready, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect blend of historic charm and modern convenience. Built in 1890 and situated on 0.84 acres in the Cooperstown School District, the property features 1,908 square feet of living space, a full usable basement, and a large two-story barn/shop ideal for storage, hobbies, or workshop space. Extensive renovations include updated electrical and plumbing systems, improved insulation, drywall, flooring, lighting, doors, trim, and hardware throughout. The floor plan was redesigned to improve functionality with a new staircase, reconfigured second-floor layout, added bedroom closets, and a beautifully remodeled bathroom. The home features a sunroom, laundry room, bonus room, walk-in closet, gas range, and oil-fired forced-air heat. Waterproof luxury vinyl flooring runs throughout the main living areas, with carpeting in the bedrooms. The basement has been significantly upgraded with concrete floors, spray-foam in

Nestled on nearly 7 private wooded acres just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown, Cooperstown School district, this beautifully maintained one-owner home offers the perfect balance of privacy, nature, and modern convenience. Set well back from the road with a long circular driveway, this peaceful retreat is surrounded by mature trees, walking trails, and abundant wildlife. The sun-filled multi-level home features soaring cathedral ceilings with exposed wood beams, expansive windows, hardwood floors, and an inviting open floor plan designed for comfortable everyday living and entertaining. The custom kitchen showcases handcrafted oak cabinetry built from trees harvested right on the property, granite tile countertops, and opens seamlessly to the dining area with access to a screened porch overlooking the peaceful surroundings. A cozy sitting area with a pellet stove creates the perfect gathering space, while the spacious living room offers operable skylights and beautiful natural l

This grand country estate on 66+ acres is ideal for horse lovers, homesteaders, or anyone seeking a peaceful rural lifestyle. The home retains its original character while offering a warm and inviting feel throughout. Inside, you'll find 5+ bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and multiple living areas including both a living room and family room, each with its own wood-burning fireplace. The formal dining room opens onto a patio that overlooks the fenced pastures, while a bright sunroom and spacious country kitchen—complete with custom built-ins—provide the perfect setting for daily living and entertaining. A bonus room with cathedral ceilings and a cozy wood stove leads directly out to the attached stable. The property includes approximately 13 acres of pasture, wooded acreage, and a babbling stream—ideal for watering animals, gardening, or enjoying on hot summer days. The attached 5-stall stable features a large loft above, and two additional barns offer even more space for animals or equipment

Bryn Brooke Manor. An 1884 Lakeside Landmark on Otsego Lake 6 Westridge Rd is an 8-bedroom, 8-bathroom, 6,600+ sq. Ft. Shingle Style estate built in 1884, set on nearly 3 acres overlooking Otsego Lake in Cooperstown, NY. Built in 1884 for Dr. Robert McKim and designed by the New York City architecture firm Babb, Cook & Willard, this is one of the finest surviving examples of American Shingle Style architecture in the region. Architectural historian Richard G. Wilson called it one of the best examples of the Shingle Style country house he had seen. A house, in his words, that should be treasured. Its architectural lineage stands alongside the Charles Atwater House in New Haven and the William Low House by McKim, Mead & White, placing it in genuinely rare company. The setting does the rest of the work. From the wraparound porches and the two-story turret, the view runs straight across Otsego Lake to the Otesaga Hotel and the Leatherstocking Golf Course. Cooperstown's two most recognizabl