14 properties for sale in Pitcher Springs

Would you like a piece of history nestled in a small-town of South Otselic in Upstate, NY? Charming historic octagon house offering a rare architectural gem with timeless character. This unique eight-sided residence showcases period details and exciting opportunities. Unique office spaces, a B&B or a fancy residential home are some ideas for purchasing it. It has an open eat-in size kitchen, a large front room, four bedrooms, 1.5 baths, and a nice deep back yard. It needs painting on the outside, and a fresh coat of paint and tlc on the inside. But once this is completed you will have an amazing piece of history and a distinctive property with classic appeal. Whatever your usage may be, it certainly is a one-of-a-kind property. This is priced to sell quickly!

Welcome to 124 Ridge Road in the town of South Otselic. This ranch-style home rests on nearly 7 acres, featuring a pond in the upper corner and a large area of tillable land. The home includes three bedrooms and two full baths. Upon entry, the wood-accented foyer leads to a living room on the right and an eat-in kitchen on the left, which also provides access to the two-car garage and basement. Off the living room, you’ll find the three bedrooms, first-floor laundry, and a full bath. The basement features a partially finished rec room, a full bath with a stand-up shower, a safe room, and a walkout to the lower yard. Enjoy easy commutes to East Syracuse, Cortland, and Binghamton from this peaceful setting

Looking for an affordable property with room to make it your own? This South Otselic home offers an excellent opportunity for investors, first-time buyers, or anyone looking for a project with potential. While the home could use significant updates, it provides a solid starting point to create a space that fits your vision and budget. The property features a covered front porch, public water, septic, and high-speed internet availability. Whether you’re planning a renovation, searching for an investment property, or looking for an affordable place to call home, this property offers plenty of possibilities. Conveniently located on State Highway 26 with easy access to nearby communities, local amenities, and outdoor recreation, this property combines affordability with opportunity. Bring your ideas and see everything this property has to offer

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This is a Real Estate-Owned (REO)/post-foreclosure home owned or managed by a bank. All offers are considered; however, the highest and best will most likely be accepted

Welcome to 132 Hicks Lane, a beautifully maintained year-round residence situated on the shores of pristine Genegantslet Lake. Widely regarded as one of the cleanest and most well-preserved lakes in Central New York and the Southern Tier, Genegantslet Lake encompasses approximately 108 acres with depths approaching 40 feet and is well stocked with a variety of fish species. Enjoy the tranquility of this private lake community jet skis and water-skiing are prohibited, preserving the peaceful atmosphere and natural beauty that make this destination so special. This quality-built waterfront home offers four bedrooms and an open, light-filled floor plan designed to capture breathtaking lake and countryside views. Cathedral tongue-and-groove ceilings, expansive windows, beautiful hardwood flooring, and a cozy woodstove create a warm and inviting living space. The spacious living room flows seamlessly into the dining area and easy-working kitchen featuring a convenient breakfast bar, making

Step into a rare and extraordinary retreat where history, design, and nature come together. This architect-designed barn conversion, originally built in the early 1800s, preserves the charm of its original construction with hand-hewn beams and solid locally sourced pine floors, while offering modern comforts throughout. The open kitchen, dining, and living space features soaring cathedral ceilings and sliding glass doors to a back deck overlooking the expansive acreage. The kitchen is thoughtfully appointed with granite countertops, blonde maple shaker cabinets, and stainless steel appliances—perfect for everyday living or entertaining in style. The main house offers three bedrooms and three full bathrooms, including a first-floor primary suite with a jetted soaking tub and glass shower, a flexible bedroom or office with deck access, and an upstairs large bedroom with a walk-in closet and full bath with a tiled shower. Central air conditioning ensures year-round comfort. A separate 20x

Set along the Otselic River Valley, this inviting home offers nearly six acres of waterfront property with scenic views and abundant outdoor enjoyment. Elevated above the flood zone, the residence features a spacious deck, stone patio, and screened porch — perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Inside, you’ll find an updated kitchen, generous dining and living areas, three bedrooms, 1.5 baths, second-floor laundry, and two bonus rooms. A walk-in pantry adds convenience, while the basement and two-stall garage provide additional space, including plumbing for a potential third bath. With modern updates, ample storage, and river frontage, this property combines comfort with natural beauty

Enjoy peaceful country living in this gorgeous 2-bedroom, 2-bath ranch home situated on 1.5 acres in South Otselic. Built in 2010, this well-maintained home that offers the convenience of one-level living with an open, comfortable layout and an attached two-bay garage. The spacious primary suite features a private bath, creating the perfect retreat. It even includes a jacuzzi tub. The full, unfinished basement provides endless possibilities for additional living space, a workshop, or extra storage. Adding to the property's unique character is a portion of the original 1900s home, which was thoughtfully rehabilitated and most recently used by the current owner as a sugar house. This versatile building features a solid concrete floor, ample workspace, a usable second floor for storage, electric service, and a covered patio area surrounding the structure ideal for hobbies, entertaining, or a variety of other uses. Experience the charm of country living while enjoying modern comforts and p

Beautiful property, just short of 9 acres. Perfect for animals, crops, hobby farm, camping. Mostly open meadow with woods in the back. The Brackel Creek borders the back corner and a small pond is located near the old barn. Move in ready 1994 Doublewide with a 5 year old shingle roof, new sewer line with concrete septic tank installed in 2004. Water filtration system ensures clean, clear water. Property is not in a flood zone. All appliances stay, lots of cabinets, 2 sheds, apple trees. Skirting is backed with wood and cement board. 200 amp electric service. Spacious master bedroom with master bath including a garden tub, double sink, shower and skylight. Freshly painted, new laminate flooring throughout. 24 hour notice required for showings

This house needs repair, with a little work, it could be a great family house. Lots of bedrooms for a large family and has a detached 2 car garage. Priced to sell

Priced reduced! Modern home in beautiful country setting. On a beautiful 7+ acre lot surrounded by farmland, sits this modern colonial-style home. Enjoy modern country living with views, large yard and ATV trails. Classic floorplan with nice archways and flow. Foyer with large closet opens onto either the formal dining room or comfy living room. The kitchen includes ample counter space, cabinets and patio door to the large deck with private views of the back acreage and hills of the Otselic River Valley. Rounding out the first level is the laundry room and convenient half bath. The second floor has a large primary suite with en suite bath with shower, deep soaking tub and double vanity plus walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms and a second full bath complete this level. The walk-out basement has tons of potential for a huge rec room, additional bedrooms or home movie theater room. Housed in the basement are the simple modular system plug-in inverters for the solar-array. Easily remo

Welcome To 2798 Cincinnatus Road, Ideally Situated In The Heart Of Cincinnatus. This Expansive Property Offers Significant Potential, As It Is Zoned For Mixed Use. Providing You The Opportunity For Conversion Into A Single-Family Home, Duplex, Or The Continuation Of The Existing Storefront. The Second Floor Boasts A Generously-Sized Bedroom, A Colossal Living Room, And A Kitchen. Property Needs Rehab. As Is

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This is a Real Estate-Owned (REO)/post-foreclosure home owned or managed by a bank. All offers are considered; however, the highest and best will most likely be accepted

Discover your private 3-acre retreat less than 4 hours from NYC. Built in 2023, this stunning 3,500 sq ft home blends high-end finishes with wide-open, airy living spaces and spectacular views from every angle. Enjoy a gourmet kitchen with granite countertops and stainless appliances, radiant-heat baths with oversized walk-in showers, and a bright, modern layout perfect for everyday living or weekend escapes. The large lower level offers endless possibilities. Entertaining space, gym, bar, or recreation room. Outdoors, the property features two small ponds, deeded lake rights at Plymouth Reservoir, and direct access to adjacent state land and snowmobile trails. A rare opportunity to unplug, unwind, and experience true Upstate tranquility!

Three-bedroom, one-bath ranch situated on 2.8 scenic acres offering a nice setback from the road. The interior features a spacious living room highlighted by a large picture window, along with an inviting eat-in kitchen offering solid wood cabinetry, ample counter space and convenient first-floor laundry. Three generously sized bedrooms include one with warm tongue-and-groove wood paneling, while hardwood flooring extends throughout much of the main living area. Bedrooms and main living space offer ample closet storage space. A large enclosed rear porch provides additional space and direct access to both the kitchen and full basement. The open basement offers abundant storage and potential for future finishing or workshop space. With some cosmetic updating, this solid home could truly shine. Outside, the property offers plenty of level yard space for recreation, gardening, entertaining or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. A detached two-bay garage provides parking and addition

Built in 1850, this remarkable 3,760 sq. Ft. home offers an impressive combination of historic character, timeless charm, and exceptional recreational amenities. Situated on 11.31 beautiful acre, the property welcomes you with outstanding curb appeal and features distinctive period details throughout, including gorgeous wide-plank floors. In addition to the awesome setting, Tuscarora Lake is directly across the road presenting access and a wonderful view. The spacious home offers four bedrooms, two full baths, two half baths, a large eat-in kitchen that ties nicely to the family room, an office with a private entrance, and a bonus area that can be used for an extra bed if needed providing plenty of room for family or guests. A unique vehicle accessible basement adds tremendous versatility for storage, workshop space, hobbies, and recreational vehicles. Outside is where this property sets itself apart from many others. The grounds feature a spectacular pond, barn, and shed, along with a

Welcome to this sweet and sun-filled 2-bedroom home with the flexibility of a potential third bedroom, home office, or guest space to fit your lifestyle. Large windows and tall ceilings fill the home with natural light, creating the most inviting atmosphere. Thoughtful updates include cherry hardwood floors and efficient mini-split system for year-round comfort. Outside, you'll appreciate the manageable yard and when you're ready for adventure, you'll love boating and fishing on Tuscarora Lake or the miles of scenic trails and expansive state land for hiking, hunting, snowmobiling and exploring all within minutes. Perfectly situated to enjoy the best of small-town living, you'll be close to local favorites like The Blue Canoe for a great meal and Johnny Appleseed Country Store for shopping and seasonal treats. The property could benefit from some TLC beyond what the photos reveal, but the potential is undeniable. Bring your ideas and transform it into your own! Whether you're searching

Well maintained duplex featuring charming original details, including beautiful old molding throughout. Each apartment offers two bedrooms and one full bath, with recently updated kitchens and bathrooms. The property is thoughtfully set up with separate furnaces, hot water tanks, electric meters, oil tanks, washers, and dryers for each unit, making it ideal for owner occupancy or investment. Each apartment has its own driveway for convenient off-street parking. Enjoy a nice backyard with a patio area and a raised garden bed, perfect for relaxation and gardening. This is a wonderful opportunity to own a cared for two family home with character, updates, and practical separate utilities. Also listed as single family MLS # S1693-

A rare opportunity to enjoy beautiful Tuscarora Lake at an affordable price point! This charming 704 square foot seasonal camp offers deeded lake rights along with a dock space for your boat and the perfect key to enjoying lake life all summer long. The property features one bedroom and one full bath, with the possibility of an additional bedroom in the basement. Relax or entertain on the deck while taking in beautiful views of Tuscarora Lake. Whether you're looking for a peaceful weekend getaway, a summer retreat, or an affordable way to gain access to this desirable lake, this property offers a unique opportunity that is hard to find. Bring your boat, settle in and start making lake memories a part of your life

Charming small-town setting meets flexible multi-generational living in this New Woodstock property with a full in-law suite. This spacious residence offers the main living quarters plus a private in-law suite — ideal for extended family, guests, or a home office/studio setup. Both the main area and the suite are ready for a full cosmetic and mechanical update, giving you the chance to customize every detail to your taste while building instant equity along the way. Tucked into the quiet hamlet of New Woodstock, you're just a short drive from Cazenovia and the greater Syracuse area, so you get small-town peace without sacrificing convenience. Great bones, endless potential — bring your contractor and your vision

Opportunity is knocking in Erieville! Located just a short walk from beautiful Tuscarora Lake and within the highly sought after Cazenovia School District, this property is now offered at an even more attractive price of just $49,999. With 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, and a flexible floor plan, this home offers plenty of possibilities for the buyer with vision. Character features like exposed beams and a wood stove create a warm, rustic feel, while the kitchen opens to a deck overlooking the yard. A first-floor bedroom, first-floor laundry, bonus rooms, attic storage, and additional upstairs space provide more room and versatility than you might expect. Outside, you'll find a storage shed, fire pit, and yard space ready to be enjoyed or reimagined. Whether you're looking for your next renovation project, an investment opportunity, or an affordable property in a desirable location, there is plenty of potential to unlock here. Property is being sold as-is. With a price like this and a location ne

Welcome to this spacious ranch home! Inside features include living room with new pellet stove, eat in kitchen with stainless steel appliances with sliding glass doors to deck, a family room with cathedral ceiling, a primary suite with full bathroom, 2 more bedrooms and updated full bath. Outside you will find an attached garage, a carport, a shed, a new metal roof, all with a picturesque backyard to enjoy. Call today to schedule your showing!

This is a Real Estate-Owned (REO)/post-foreclosure home owned or managed by a bank. All offers are considered; however, the highest and best will most likely be accepted

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This home is in preforeclosure, which means the homeowner is in default (missed payments). Therefore, there could be an opportunity to strike a great deal with the owner and the bank

This is a Real Estate-Owned (REO)/post-foreclosure home owned or managed by a bank. All offers are considered; however, the highest and best will most likely be accepted