57 properties for sale in Witmer Manor

Enjoy the lake lifestyle on Witmer Lake with this charming channel-front property offering 2.5 lots, a spacious. 36 acre level lot, and 129 feet of channel frontage. Located on the Indian Chain of Lakes, this home gives you access to Witmer, Dallas, Messick, Westler, and Hackenberg Lakes for boating, fishing, and relaxing on the water. Inside, youll find a comfortable living area, a functional kitchen with dining space and pantry, 2 bedrooms, and 2 full bathrooms. The layout offers a cozy and practical setup whether you are looking for a year-round home, weekend getaway, or lake retreat. Outside, enjoy peaceful water views from both the front and back of the home, along with a wood deck overlooking the channel that is perfect for entertaining or unwinding after a day on the water. Additional storage includes an 8x10 storage shed and a 20x28 detached garage, giving you plenty of room for lake toys, tools, and equipment. This is a great opportunity to own 2.5 lots on the Indian Chain of

Highly sought after Eagles Addition that borders Witmer Lake and has a shared neighborhood lake access just a short walk, or golf cart ride to launch your kayak, or paddleboard. This 3 bedroom, 2 1/2 bath home nestled on a cul-de-sac lane includes a full basement that has a bathroom and hook ups to add your bar/kitchen area for you to finish off. The main level has an open living, dining, and kitchen area that makes entertaining easy. The large family room has vaulted ceilings with many windows that allow you to enjoy the partially wooded back yard, with a deck to the back yard. The primary has its own full bathroom, there are 2 other bedrooms, and another full bath on the main level. There is a laundry room off of the attached 2 car garage. This home has a park like feel, surrounded by trees. Running, biking, walking around this lake neighborhood is easy and feels like a campground during the Summer

(USDA financing may be available for qualified buyers, potentially offering 0% down payment. Buyer eligibility and loan terms subject to lender approval) Spacious 5-bedroom ranch offering 2,970 square feet on the main level with a full unfinished basement that, when finished, would bring the total living space to approximately 5,796 square feet. The main floor features four bedrooms, including two large bedrooms with private en-suite bathrooms, plus two additional half baths. A fifth bedroom is located in the basement. The open-concept floor plan includes a large living room with new doors and windows, a generous kitchen with eat-at bar seating, and a sizable bonus room perfect for an office, playroom, or additional living space. Laundry is conveniently located on the first floor. The basement is dry, insulated, has a vapor barrier installed, and is prepped for drywallmaking it ready for finishing. Situated on just over half an acre, this property offers a peaceful country feel with no

A truly exceptional property in LaGrange County two parcels totaling 40 acres with an impressive 1,200 feet of lakefront on beautiful Royer Lake and over 3,000 feet of combined road frontage (more than 2,000 feet on one side and 1,000 feet on the other). This property offers a rare blend of rolling farmland, mature trees and serene waterfront, making it an ideal setting for recreation, investment, or development. Currently zoned Agricultural and under cultivation, it provides both income potential and flexibility for future use. Included on the property is a 1,120 sq. Ft. home featuring 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, on a walkout basement already plumbed for second bathroom. The home is positioned to take in the quiet, rural surroundings and offers an excellent opportunity for guest quarters, or a temporary residence while you plan your dream build. Royer Lake is a peaceful, non-ski lake known for its great fishing and connection to Fish Lake, offering the best of quiet lake living with expansive

This show-stopping, fully renovated home offers five bedrooms and three full bathrooms. The kitchen and bathrooms have been completely remodeled, highlighted by a custom master shower. Major systems are new, including a roof, windows, HVAC and ductwork, upgraded electrical, and updated plumbing. Enjoy outdoor entertaining on the new front and rear decks and take advantage of the large double lot. Not often available: a home of this size, fully remodeled and so close to the lake all at a great price

Water so clean it looks green! Cleanest lake water in all of lagrange county. Ski lakefront. Southern exposure. 3 lakes. Custom kitchen and baths. 24 x 36 partially heated garage. Clean clear water. Great beach/swimming. Boat lift and pier included. 1930s ski lakefront cottage meets modern day living! Opportunities like this on the Oliver Lake Chain do not come around often. This well-maintained 3 bedroom, 2 full bath lakefront home sits on a spacious 0.34-acre lot with 87.4 feet of frontage on all-sports Oliver Lake known for its exceptionally clear, spring-fed and glacial waters, outstanding swimming, and trout stocking/fishing. Oliver Lake connects to both Olin Lake and Martin Lake, forming one of the largest natural undeveloped spring-fed/glacial lake systems in Northeast Indiana. Inside, the home there is 1,876 finished square feet of living space. The custom kitchen by River Woodworking features quartz countertops, soft close doors and drawers, and included appliances, while bath

Experience exceptional lakefront living on Sylvan Lake, a 669-acre all-sports lake, with 90 feet of prime waterfront on desirable Kerr Island in Rome City. Situated on a rare level lot, this beautifully remodeled year-round home offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and effortless lakeside living. Completely transformed by the current owners, this move-in-ready residence features 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and thoughtfully designed spaces for entertaining and relaxing. The stunning kitchen showcases handcrafted Amish cabinetry with pull-out storage behind every door, generous workspace, and a Frigidaire Professional stainless steel refrigerator. The open-concept living and dining areas flow seamlessly together, complemented by a wet bar and expansive windows that capture breathtaking lake views from nearly every room. The spacious lakeside living room opens through oversized glass doors to an expansive deckideal for morning coffee, afternoon sunbathing, or evening cocktails overlook

This move-in ready 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch home in Rome City offers comfortable one-level living on a large, peaceful lot surrounded by mature trees and a relaxing wooded setting. Step inside to a clean, updated interior featuring newer carpet, fresh paint throughout, and a practical floor plan designed for everyday convenience. Major updates completed in 2014 include the furnace, central air, roof, water softener, water heater, and vinyl siding, giving buyers peace of mind on many of the homes big-ticket items. Additional updates in 2021 include new bathroom vanities, tub/shower, interior paint, and refrigerator. The attached garage includes extra storage space and a mechanical room, adding function and flexibility. Outside, the spacious lot provides room to relax, entertain, garden, or simply enjoy the quiet Oak Shores atmosphere with nearby walking areas and natural surroundings. The Oak Shores Association provides residents with lake access to Tamarack Lake, part of the 4 West Lake

Stunning Waldron Lake lakefront home with 112' of Lake frontage, offering over 3,100 sq ft and one of the larger homes on the lake! Inside features bamboo hand-scraped hardwood floors, vaulted ceilings, as well as tray ceilings, along with high-end Grabill custom cabinetry throughout. The main kitchen includes granite countertops on island /top, and breakfast bar seating, complemented by a second fully equipped kitchen(appliances included, excluding secondary refrigerator), plus washer and dryer. Additional highlights include a stone dual-view fireplace, heated tile floors in the master bath, Pella & North Star windows with built-in blinds, central vac, whole-home audio, and geothermal HVAC with generator hookup. (Please Note: The Geothermal system has 2 large water heaters to always provide instant warm water w/ constant pressure! )With the separate 2nd kitchen / bedroom areas, it could also be used for a rental / income generating property with flex areas. A custom spa retreat additi

Summer is here, perfect timing to tour this beautifully situated Sylvan Lake lakefront home. This 4-bedroom, 2-bath property offers sweeping lake views and direct waterfront access with a flat yard. The main level features an open concept floor plan with abundant natural light and seamless flow to the lakefront deck, ideal for entertaining or relaxing by the water. An oversized, heated 1-car garage provides excellent storage for lake gear, and the spacious yard offers plenty of room to accommodate a tritoon or large bass boat. Whether your passion is fishing, boating, swimming, or simply taking in the views, Sylvan Lake delivers the full lake life experience. This is an exceptional opportunity to own a true waterfront retreat

Welcome to this inviting 3-bedroom, 2-bath country home nestled on 2 tranquil acres of open countryside. Thoughtfully designed for both comfort and functionality, the home features a massive open-concept living area perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or simply enjoying the natural light and views that pour through the large windows. The main floor primary bedroom offers convenient single-level living, while the additional bedrooms upstairs provide plenty of space for family or guests. Two full bathrooms ensure comfort and privacy for everyone. Step outside to experience peaceful rural living at its best a beautiful patio area is perfect for morning coffee, evening dinners, or stargazing nights. The property also includes a fully functional barn, ideal for housing animals, creating a workshop, or storing equipment. Set in a quiet country setting, this property offers the rare combination of wide-open space, fresh air, and modern comfort all while being just a short drive from local ame

One of Tamarack Lakes most exceptional propertiesnearly 2 acres & 300 feet of frontage for a private, spacious lakefront lifestyle perfect for gathering, entertaining, & enjoying the water. Inside, natural light floods through a wall of windows, highlighting the open-concept design & stunning water views. The main level is ideal for everyday living & easy entertaining, anchored by a spacious living room w/ gas log fireplace & built-in bookshelves. The eat-in kitchen features abundant cabinetry, quartz countertops, custom backsplash, touch faucet, Frigidaire appliances, pantry, & a wraparound breakfast bar connecting to the casual dining nook. Beyond, the hearth room offers an additional fireplace & more lake viewsideal for relaxing evenings. The primary suite on the main level is a retreat, with a tray ceiling, fireplace, walk-in closet, & a spacious ensuite bath with heated tile floors, dual sinks, walk-in shower, & jetted corner tub. An office (or extra bedroom), full shared bath, &

N & open house announcement*. Join me on SUNDAY JULY 19th from 1-4. Two backlots! There is still plenty of time to do summer activities, entertain friends, and enjoy the seasons at your new lake home. Bring an offer and your swim suit! Rare opportunity to purchase a lakefront home on Waldron's main basin. Enjoy all the West Lakes Chain has to offer. Skiing from 10:00AM. 5:00PM on Waldron, or take a float on Steinbarger, Tamarack, and Jones Lakes. A very special FEATURE this property has is not one, but TWO BACKLOTS. One of the lots already has an oversized 2-car garage with a wide open lofted space above. Use your imagination on what this added space could be for you. The other lot can be utilized for toy storage in the off season and additional parking in the summer when everyone will want to be at your place enjoying the water sports. Maybe the open lot is good location for your annual cornhole tourney. The outdoorsman will enjoy fantastic FISHING, boating, and waterfowl hunting just

Step back in time while enjoying the comforts of modern living with this beautiful two-story brick farmhouse, originally built in 1830 and beautifully updated throughout. Nestled on 20 acres, this one-of-a-kind property offers the perfect blend of historic charm, timeless craftsmanship, and endless opportunity. Inside, youll fall in love with the character and warmth this home offers, from the 9+ foot ceilings to the upgrades that complement the homes original charm. The remodeled kitchen features gorgeous knotted hickory cabinetry installed just 8 years ago, creating a warm and inviting space that is both functional and beautiful. Nearly every window in the home has approximately 20 years remaining on its transferable warranty, offering peace of mind for years to come. The spacious layout includes three bedrooms upstairs, along with a potential fourth bedroom, office, or den on the main level. Outside is where this property truly shines. With multiple outbuildings offering incredible

Motivated seller that says make an offer and in case you missed it they're throwing in a one year home warranty! 578 of an acre on fish and royer lake chain! 2 bedrooms. Open concept living. 50 feet of lakefront. 2 backlots. Exceptional neighbors. Enjoy lake life right away with immediate possession at closing, giving you plenty of time to make the most of the season before winter arrives and just in time for ice fishing. Same owners for nearly 30 years, this year-round Royer Lake home offers 2 bedrooms, a LARGE full bathroom, a 10' x 17' lakeside sunroom, and an attached 18' x 24' garage. Open concept living at it finest with updates including: vinyl plank flooring, tile flooring in the sunroom, a metal roof, vinyl siding, an updated furnace, and all kitchen appliances are included, making this home move-in ready so you can start enjoying lake life from day one. Inside from the attached garage or front entry theres a convenient main-level laundry room just before entering the open-con

50 feet of prime lakefront on the highly desirable Royer/Fish Lake chain can now be yours! This cherished family propertyheld for generationshas been well loved and is finally ready for its next owners to enjoy peaceful lake living and unforgettable sunsets. The west-facing home sits on a spacious double lot (two platted Royer Lake Resort lots) with a 2-car garage, utility shed, and ample parking. Inside, the open-concept layout features a cozy fieldstone fireplace as the heart of the kitchen, dining, and living spaces. The lakeside primary bedroom offers gorgeous morning views and beautiful sunsets, while two additional bedrooms provide privacy for family or guests. Recent updates include freshly painted kitchen cabinets, refurbished countertops, new luxury vinyl tile plank flooring, and beautiful lake views while you cook. The refreshed bathroom features a new vanity, resurfaced tub, updated fixtures, and new flooring. A spacious mudroom/laundry area adds convenient storage. Energy-e

Experience life on The Narrows, where every day begins and ends with the beauty of the lake. With 40 feet of frontage on 669-acre all-sports Sylvan Lake, this well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers over 2,000 square feet and is ready for gathering, relaxing, and making memories. Located on the north side of The Narrows, you'll enjoy panoramic water views, passing boats, and easy access to every corner of the lake. Inside, the open main level connects the kitchen, dining area, and family room, creating a comfortable space for everyday living and entertaining. Exposed wood beams, updated flooring, a wood-burning stove, and large lakeside windows keep the water as the focal point. The kitchen features stainless steel appliances, painted upper cabinets, oak lower cabinets, laminate countertops, a tile backsplash, recessed lighting, and plenty of cabinet and prep space. A main-level office with a built-in Murphy bed offers flexibility for overnight guests or working from home, while

Welcome to lake life! This beautifully updated cottage offers the perfect blend of charm, comfort, and breathtaking water views. Featuring 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath, this move-in-ready retreat boasts a spacious kitchen, dining area, and two separate living spacesproviding plenty of room to relax and entertain. Step outside to the large deck overlooking the lake, perfect for morning coffee, evening sunsets, and gathering with family and friends. The flat lot offers easy access to the water, while the storage shed provides plenty of space for all your lake toys and outdoor gear. Whether you're looking for a weekend getaway or a year-round home, this lakefront gem is ready for you to start making memories

Escape to your own 3.27-acre country retreat, where peaceful sunrises, open space, and modern comfort come together. This spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offers multiple levels of living and entertaining, giving everyone room to spread out and enjoy. The gourmet kitchen is the heart of the home, featuring custom oak cabinetry, a large eat-in island with sink and cooktop, and skylights that fill the space with natural light. The dining room flows seamlessly from the kitchen and opens to the back deck, where you can savor quiet mornings overlooking the countryside to the East. The main level includes two generous bedrooms, including a primary suite with French doors that lead directly to the backyard and deck. The living rooms large casement window and cozy pellet stove make it the perfect gathering space on cool Indiana evenings. Upstairs, youll find two oversized bedrooms, a full bath, and abundant storage ideal for guests, hobbies, or a private home office. The finished basement expan

Rare Find! 125 Feet of Lakefront on Atwood Lake + Back Lot. Dont miss this rare opportunity to own a prime lakefront property on beautiful Atwood Lake. With 125 feet of shoreline, a newer seawall, and a sandy beach, this is the perfect building spot for your dream lake home. Enjoy breathtaking sunsets and unobstructed lake views from this stunning location. The existing cottage is a true handyman specialready for renovation or replacement, depending on your vision. Directly across the road, a spacious back lot offers endless possibilities: build a large garage, pole barn, or create additional parking for guests. A 10x10 utility shed is also included for storing your lake toys and gear. Opportunities like this dont come along oftenseize the chance to build your perfect lake getaway on one of the best spots Atwood Lake has to offer! No Pier is included with the sale as there no longer is one

Come see this incredible home on dallas lake, lagrange indiana's premier all sports sun-up to sun-down recreation lake. 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, sitting on just under half an acre with direct access to a ski lake. This is the first time this home has been offered in 30 years, tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac along the Indian Chain of Lakes. This ranch with a walkout basement offers about 150 feet of channel frontage, with easy access to Witmer, Westler, Hackenburg, and Messick Lakes. Built in 1993, it has 2,576 finished square feet and sits on a deep, wide and easy to navigate channel that you can leave your piers and boat lifts in all winter (BOAT LIFT EXCLUDED). Out back (street side), mature trees line the street leading to a semi-circle concrete driveway and a 3-car attached garage thats finished and insulated. Out front (lakefront), the yard is big, level, and set up perfectly for yard games or just relaxing by the water. Theres also a 14x18 lakeside shed for all your gear, an incl

Looking for more space? This 4 bedroom 2 bathroom home sits on almost a half acre with 2 covered porches, 2 living spaces, and a huge heated 30 X 32 detached garage/workshop. Detached garage features a 3rd garage door on the back and a huge attic space for additional storage. The 9 foot ceilings and hardwood floors create a farm house feel with modern touches. Master bedroom is located on the main floor with a walk-in closet, main level laundry, and large kitchen. In addition, this home just had new exterior doors installed and some new flooring

Enjoy stunning lake views from this beautifully updated Sylvan Lake home in Rome City! Completely remodeled in recent years, this spacious 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom lakefront retreat offers over 3,100 square feet of living space designed for entertaining, relaxing, and making memories with family and friends. The open-concept main level features a gorgeous updated kitchen with quartz countertops, black stainless steel appliances, waterfall island, and modern lighting. The adjoining living room showcases a breathtaking wall of windows overlooking the lake, filling the home with natural light and incredible views. Upstairs, all four bedrooms are tucked away for privacy, including access to a beautifully updated full bath with double sink vanity and tile shower. The enormous bonus room above the garage offers endless possibilitiesperfect for guests, game nights, or a cozy movie room. The walkout basement provides even more entertaining space for gatherings, games, or relaxing after a day on t

Welcome to your dream lake retreat on stunning Sylvan Lake! This custom-built, two-story home with a full finished walkout basement offers over 2,300 sqft of thoughtfully designed living space, perfectly positioned to soak in breathtaking lake views. The open main level is made for entertaining, anchored by a magnificent wood-burning stone fireplace and a custom kitchen featuring a huge island with solid surface tops, ample cabinetry, and a spacious walk-in pantry. Step out onto the open deck and take in the absolutely stunning panoramic views of this picturesque 669-acre lake that allows all water activities! The master suite is a true sanctuary with incredible lake views and a beautifully customized bath. The finished lower level walks out to a concrete patio and is plumbed for a wet bar and offers a half bath, laundry area and plenty of storage for all your lake toys. The heated 4-car detached garage is a bonus like no other featuring upper-level living quarters with a mini split fo

Custom built in 2018, this beautiful 1,599-square-foot home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and ADA accessibility. Situated on two lots, the property boasts 94 feet of lake frontage, along with additional channel frontage directly across from an ACRES Land Trust preserve, providing a peaceful and scenic setting. Outdoor amenities are designed for both relaxation and entertaining, featuring a private swimming pool, a tranquil pond with a fountain, stone steps leading into the lake, and a fire pit perfect for enjoying evenings by the water. The property also includes two oversized 2-car garages. One garage features a second-level workshop, while the other provides convenient attic storage, offering exceptional space for hobbies, projects, and storage. Recent updates completed in 2025 include a new pool pump, a Samsung 28 cu. Ft. 4-Door French Door Refrigerator, a Samsung Smart Freestanding Electric Range, and an A. O. Smith 50-Gallon Gas Water Heater. The home is also equipped with an In